Skip to content

mp4fragment creating extra small fragment #19

@bcasinclair

Description

@bcasinclair

I have been finding that mp4fragment has been creating an extra audio fragment with only 3 samples even though the previous fragment has less than the maximum number of samples for the specified duration.

Using this sample file: http://asbctest.s3.amazonaws.com/debug/muxed.mp4

Result looks like this
mp4fragment --verbosity 3 muxed.mp4 cokead_frag.m4f
found regular I-frame interval: 200 frames (at 25.000 frames per second)
fragment: track ID 1 200 samples
fragment: track ID 2 345 samples
fragment: track ID 1 200 samples
fragment: track ID 2 344 samples
fragment: track ID 1 200 samples
fragment: track ID 2 345 samples
fragment: track ID 1 150 samples
fragment: track ID 2 258 samples
fragment: track ID 2 3 samples

As the video is 25fps 200 samples per fragment is exactly on 8 seconds as per the encode and the audio is 44.1Khz so should be 43 packets of 1024 samples second == 344.5 samples.

So are the last 2 fragments for track 2 258 and 3? Shouldn't it be one last fragment of 261 samples? Even if I adjust the fragment duration to longer than the video I still get one last audio fragment of 3 samples.

The result is that when it runs through mp4split is that it is generating one more audio segment than video segment and this is causing some players to error.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions