When using ECS with EC2 instances (hosts), no pb; but when using Fargate, we don't have any Security Group associated with the container instances registered to the cluster, so why it's needed at the import ?
Reproduction Steps
For example, you create a Cluster in a Stack A :
const EcsCluster = new ecs.Cluster(this, 'EcsCluster', {
vpc: vpc,
clusterName: EcsClusterName,
containerInsights: true
});
const SecurityGroupEcsHost = new ec2.SecurityGroup(this, 'SecurityGroupEcsHost', {
vpc: vpc,
allowAllOutbound: true,
description: 'Security Group for ECS Host'
});
AutoScalingGroupEcsHost.addSecurityGroup(SecurityGroupEcsHost);
EcsCluster.addAutoScalingGroup(AutoScalingGroupEcsHost;
And you want to create an ECS EC2Service in another Stack B :
clusterName: EcsClusterName,
vpc,
securityGroups: [SecurityGroupEcsHost]
});
No pb at this time because on the first Stack, you have provided SGR & ASG resources for Hosts Instances.
What did you expect to happen?
But now, I want to create ECS Fargate resources on the other Stack, and the SGR is created on this one because associated with Fargate Service.
const EcsClusterFargate = new ecs.Cluster(this, 'EcsClusterFargate ', {
vpc: vpc,
clusterName: EcsClusterFargateName,
containerInsights: true
});
But in that case, I can't import the dedicated Cluster like that :
const EcsClusterFargate = ecs.Cluster.fromClusterAttributes(this, 'EcsCluster', {
clusterName: EcsClusterFargateName,
vpc
});
So,, why it's mandatory ?
Do I have to attach a fake SGR ?
Environment
- CLI Version : 1.68.0
- Framework Version: 6.14.8
- Node.js Version: v12.15.0
- OS : Linux
- Language (Version): TypeScript
This is 🐛 Bug Report
When using ECS with EC2 instances (hosts), no pb; but when using Fargate, we don't have any Security Group associated with the container instances registered to the cluster, so why it's needed at the import ?
Reproduction Steps
For example, you create a Cluster in a Stack A :
And you want to create an ECS EC2Service in another Stack B :
No pb at this time because on the first Stack, you have provided SGR & ASG resources for Hosts Instances.
What did you expect to happen?
But now, I want to create ECS Fargate resources on the other Stack, and the SGR is created on this one because associated with Fargate Service.
But in that case, I can't import the dedicated Cluster like that :
So,, why it's mandatory ?
Do I have to attach a fake SGR ?
Environment
This is 🐛 Bug Report