Closing this — the skill needs more fleshing out before it can be merged. The current version only references the built-in browser_* tools, but the real value of the dogfood skill is leveraging agent-browser's richer capabilities (console error capture, annotated screenshots, video recording) that aren't yet exposed as Hermes tools.

We're putting together a more detailed plan that addresses:

• How video recordings are stored and who they're for
• How screenshot annotation works and what it annotates
• Console error vs. command execution distinction
• Whether these should be new browser tools rather than terminal workarounds (likely yes — they need to connect to the live browser session)

Will reopen or create a new PR once the plan is finalized. Thanks for the contribution.

✅ Completed: Profile Form Progressive Disclosure

Implemented accordion-based progressive disclosure for the profile form to reduce cognitive overload and create a more guided onboarding experience.

Changes Made

1. Accordion Section Structure

• Converted 3 static sections (Identity, Body, Lifestyle) to collapsible accordion items
• Each section has an accordion trigger with:
  • Section number and title
  • Completion status badge (green checkmark or "X required" indicator)
  • Chevron icon for expand/collapse

2. Quick Start Mode (First-Run)

• Added toggle between "Quick start" and "Full profile" modes
• Quick start shows only critical fields (Name, Email, Weight, Activity Level)
• Optional fields (Birth date, Body fat %, Sex, Equipment, Dietary) hidden behind expandable sections
• Toggle button allows users to expand all sections when ready

3. Progress Feedback

• Section-level progress badges show completion status:
  • ✓ Green checkmark for complete sections
  • "2 required" or "1 of 2 done" for incomplete sections
  • "Optional" badge for Lifestyle section
• Critical path celebration banner appears when Name, Email, and Weight are filled

4. Smart Default Expansion

• First incomplete section is automatically expanded on load
• Returning users see all sections expanded
• Users can manually expand/collapse any section

Acceptance Criteria Status

• Implement progressive disclosure (collapsed sections)
• Clear indication of required vs optional fields via badges
• Progress feedback at section level (checkmarks/counters)
• "Quick start" option to get to first plan faster
• Celebration/reward for completing critical path (green banner with animation)

Technical Notes

• Uses @base-ui/react Accordion component
• All 537 tests pass (profile-form, profile-screen, profile-page tests)
• One pre-existing Today page test failure unrelated to these changes
• No new lint errors introduced

Verification

• npm test - all profile-related tests pass
• npm run build - successful compilation
• npm run lint - no new errors

Deployed to Railway: https://vantage-production-b8d9.up.railway.app

Code Review Summary

Verdict: Changes Requested (3 critical security issues, 2 code quality issues)

🔴 Critical

• SKILL.md:58 — No URL scheme validation before navigation. Malicious prompts could redirect the agent to phishing/internal pages.
• SKILL.md:112 — Auto-downloads files without MIME type allowlisting. Executable payloads could be written to disk → RCE risk.
• issue-taxonomy.md:34 — Console error collection lacks secret/PII redaction step. Credentials in bug reports exposed to repo readers.

⚠️ Code Quality

• dogfood-report-template.md:12 — Missing "Expected Behavior" section in repro steps. Hinders triage.
• SKILL.md:89 — No error-handling defined for phase failures. Silent failures produce incomplete reports marked as complete.

✅ Looks Good

• Well-structured severity/category taxonomy
• Clean separation into SKILL.md / references / templates following agentskills.io standard
• Solid bug report template with required evidence fields

Reviewed by Hermes Agent