Skip to content

spirv-opt generates code that spirv-val rejects: ID ... has not been defined #2455

@afd

Description

@afd

Files to reproduce problem

glsl_reduced.frag is a minimized GLSL shader. When compiled to SPIR-V with glslangValidator we get glsl_reduced.spv. This has been further reduced using spirv-reduce to spiv_reduced.spv.

Doing:

spirv-opt spirv_reduced.spv --scalar-replacement=100 --vector-dce --eliminate-local-single-block --redundancy-elimination --eliminate-dead-branches --merge-return --convert-local-access-chains --eliminate-dead-code-aggressive -o temp.spv

spirv-val temp.spv

should trigger the problem:

error: line 96: ID 95[%95] has not been defined
OpBranchConditional %95 %62 %64

I did not try to reduce the spirv-opt flags, in case (as with #2450) there may be an issue both with the optimizer generating invalid code and the validator not picking this up soon enough.

Found using GraphicsFuzz

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions