Skip to content

Secondary LDAP server not evaluated when the first one has failed #5590

@bmfmancini

Description

@bmfmancini

When you have multiple LDAP servers configured in the auth settings the expected behaviour is that cacti will evaluate the LDAP servers from left to right

with the below failure the secondary server is not evaluated

2023-11-21 11:36:17 - AUTH LOGIN FAILED: LDAP Login Failed for user 'user' from IP Address ''.
2023-11-21 11:36:17 - AUTH LOGIN FAILED: LDAP Error: Protocol Error, Unable to bind, LDAP result: (Can't contact LDAP server) on Server (ldap hostname)
2023-11-21 11:36:17 - AUTH LDAP: Protocol Error, Unable to bind, LDAP result: (Can't contact LDAP server) on Server (ldap hostsname)
``

However in ling/ldap I see the following error conditions are checked and it does not include this error 

		/* unable to bind */
		$ldap_error = ldap_errno($ldap_conn);
		if ($ldap_error == 0x02) {
			/* protocol error */
			$output = LdapError::GetErrorDetails(LdapError::ProtocolErrorGeneral, $ldap_conn, $this->host);
		} elseif ($ldap_error == 0x31) {
			/* invalid credentials */
			$output = LdapError::GetErrorDetails(LdapError::Failure, $ldap_conn, $this->host);
		} elseif ($ldap_error == 0x32) {
			/* insufficient access */
			$output = LdapError::GetErrorDetails(LdapError::InsufficientAccess, $ldap_conn, $this->host);
		} elseif ($ldap_error == 0x51) {
			/* unable to connect to server */
			$output = LdapError::GetErrorDetails(LdapError::ConnectionUnavailable, $ldap_conn, $this->host);
		} elseif ($ldap_error == 0x55) {
			/* timeout */
			$output = LdapError::GetErrorDetails(LdapError::ConnectionTimeout, $ldap_conn, $this->host);
		} else {
			/* general bind error */
			$output = LdapError::GetErrorDetails(LdapError::ProtocolErrorBind, $ldap_conn, $this->host);
		}
	}

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugUndesired behaviourconfirmedBug is confirm by dev teamresolvedA fixed issue

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions