
If you look closely at the photograph above, you might be able to spot Anne and me in the balcony at the Beacon Theater, upper right.
It was a warm June night, and Ramy Youssef—an Egyptian American comedian—had just finished his stand-up set when someone in then audience shouted, “Mamdani!” The New York City mayoral primary was still weeks away, before Zohran Mamdani—a foreign-born American citizen, Muslim, and Democratic Socialist—would shock the country by defeating former New York governor Andrew Cuomo.
Ramy smiled and then he walked out: the future mayor.
He was followed by Mahmoud Khalil. A Columbia University graduate student and a leader in the movement opposing Israel’s genocide in Gaza, Khalil had just been released from detention and the threat of deportation. He was among the first Palestinian activists seized and punished for their speech.
The audience erupted.
It was a remarkable moment. A wonderful night.
On Thursday, a federal appeals court reversed the lower court ruling that had ordered Khalil’s release, handing the Trump administration a victory in its effort to deport Khalil. In a 2–1 decision, a panel of the Philadelphia-based Third U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed Khalil’s lawsuit challenging his detention.
In response, Mamdani condemned the ruling, calling Khalil’s arrest “more than just a chilling act of political repression—it is an attack on all of our constitutional rights,” and insisting that “Mahmoud is free—and must remain free.”
Ironically, in a separate case, U.S. District Judge William Young issued a blistering critique of the administration’s approach to free speech, warning that it reflected a “fearful” effort to “exclude from participation everyone who doesn’t agree with them.”
Young—appointed to the federal bench by President Ronald Reagan—made the remarks during a Boston hearing on remedies for the administration’s detention of pro-Palestinian students last year. He had ruled in September that senior officials had engaged in an illegal campaign to arrest and deport noncitizen students based solely on their political activism.
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi L. Noem and Secretary of State Marco Rubio, Young said, were engaged in an “unconstitutional conspiracy” to deprive individuals of their rights. “The secretary of state,” he noted, “the senior Cabinet officer in our history, is involved in this.”






