Writing is a journey, not a destination.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Tue, 16 Jun 2026 08:53:23 GMT

"Salvation" (cont.)

Warning: image heavy post.
(includes clowns).

At the end of my last post, we left Sam reeling from the mental assault of images from a nursery. There's a lot to unpack in the vision that follows, so I felt it deserved its own dedicated post.

We get the briefest flash of a musical box, then a painted clown . . .

As the vision continues, we’re shown a woman placing a baby in a crib, recalling the scene in the pilot where Mary did the same with baby Sammy, and we hear the sound of a passing train.

Sam checks the town OS map and finds a road adjoining a railway line. It’s called Grace Avenue. A positive omen for once? 😄

As he arrives at the location his vision returns, this time showing the mother standing in front of a feature arched window that Sam immediately identifies on the house across the street.

And, as luck would have it, mother and baby just happen to be walking up the road at that moment.

Claiming to have just moved in down the block, Sam strikes up a conversation with the mother, Monica, complimenting her “gorgeous” infant. “She’s such a good baby!” he asserts – an evaluation he’s able to make after seeing her for a full ten seconds! 😆 I’m not sure modern mothers would so readily accept a stranger taking such an interest in their baby, but those were more innocent times, I guess . . .

But it prompts Monica to offer the information “She never cries. She just stares at everybody. Sometimes she looks at you and, I swear, it's like she's reading your mind.”

This seems to me to be a clear hint that the baby (Rosie) has telepathic abilities already, even before the Demon’s visit. The scene convinces me that the show’s original conception was that the Demon was choosing children with innate psychic qualities that he could exploit for his own purposes. I assume the decision to depict the powers as entirely demonic in origin came later.

Of course, Sam also learns that Rosie is exactly 6 months old that day and it’s clear he wants to warn Monica of the impending danger, but he says nothing, just continues to watch her anxiously as she meets up with her husband and they enter their home.

And then the vision returns once more. Again he sees the clown and the music box, then a clock that stops (just as the one in his own nursery stopped on the night of his mother’s death).

The image of the clown is intriguing: it holds the camera’s focus for almost 15 seconds before it pans to the clock . . .

Next, we move to the shadow of a male figure that moves across the nursery floor, eventually falling over the baby’s crib.

There’s a clear visual continuity that connects the clown first to its shadow, then figuratively to the shadow of the Demon as it engulfs baby Rosie.

Finally, we see the shadowy figure of the Demon itself standing over the crib as Monica enters the room, and we watch as she's dragged up the wall and onto the ceiling until she’s suspended over Rosie’s crib. A gash opens in her stomach just like the one Mary had in the pilot, and we see her blood dripping down from the wound.

Here is something else I suspect was changed later: when we were told that Mary’s death was just bad luck; she was in the wrong place at the wrong time. To me, the striking similarities between Mary’s death and Monica’s don’t seem accidental. I believe that, originally, the mothers’ deaths were conceived as necessary and ritualistic. The babies were supposed to be demonically baptised with their mothers’ blood.

Significantly, however, on the night of Mary’s murder, the blood missed baby Sammy and hit John instead (below left). Consequently, Sam’s demonic baptism came not from his mother’s death, but from Jessica’s (below right).

s1e01

The blood baptism plays an important metaphorical role in the first season: it symbolizes the bloodlust, the obsession with revenge that infects John when he witnesses Mary’s murder, but which isn’t activated in Sam until he witnesses Jessica’s.

Only 47% of everybody loves a clown.

Now, going back to that clown mobile: here is a rumination on its possible symbolic connection with the appearance of the Demon:

Killer clowns have been much in the media in recent years following a global craze, beginning in 2016, of people dressing as creepy clowns to harass members of the public. The movie, It, featuring the sinister Pennywise came out the following year, followed by Joker in 2019. But the evil clown trope isn’t new. In fact, It was adapted from Stephen King’s 1986 novel of the same name wherein an evil clown goes on a regular spree of snatching children every 27 years . . . which seems a somewhat familiar premise . . . Joaquin Phonenix’s performance in Joker was inspired by seventies serial killer, John Wayne Gacy, who was dubbed the “killer clown” because he worked as a clown for children’s parties. And, of course, the original Joker character was first created by DC in the 1940s.

Such portrayals are generally thought to be subversions of the traditional image of clowns as jolly, innocent and harmless . . . except that conception may be neither as popular nor as traditional as we imagine. A survey conducted for the International Journal of Mental Health indicated that more than half of the population feel some degree of coulrophobia (fear of clowns).* Furthermore, a study by the University of Sheffield concluded "that clowns are universally disliked by children. Some found them quite frightening and unknowable".*

These studies discuss several possible causes for the prevalence of this discomfort: for example, some attribute it partly to a phenomenon known as the “uncanny valley” where the closer something comes to appearing human without actually being human, the more disturbing it seems; some speculate it’s triggered by the clown make-up, which masks the natural emotions of the wearer and makes them seem untrustworthy; others note that the typical make up and costumes of clowns bears a resemblance to traditional depictions of demons:

Wolfgang M. Zucker points out the similarities between a clown's appearance and the cultural depictions of demons and other infernal creatures, noting "[the clown's] chalk-white face in which the eyes almost disappear, while the mouth is enlarged to a ghoulish bigness, looks like the mask of death". *

Interestingly, of the possible causes for their fear, respondents to the IJMH survey* cited a frightening experience with an actual clown least often, so it seems the origin of this pervasive phobia is more culturally embedded and may have its roots in a more distant and darker history of the clown archetype.

(image adapted from s1e04)

Clown characters have been recorded throughout history in many different cultures, including Ancient Egypt, Greece and Rome, and they have long been associated with “death and dark truths”. They have always been chaotic characters whose function was to be unsettling; they upset the natural order, ridiculed social norms and had license to tell truth to power, like the medieval jesters who could openly mock even kings.*

The specific cultural association between clowns and demons goes back at least as far as the Middle Ages. The familiar pronged hat of the harlequin style clown, for example, was intended to recall medieval horned images of the Devil, while the name itself dates back to early French theatre:

The name Harlequin is taken from that of a mischievous "devil" or "demon" character in popular French Passion Plays. It originates with an Old French term herlequin, hellequin, first attested in the 11th century, by the chronicler Orderic Vitalis, who recounts a story of a monk who was pursued by a troop of demons when wandering on the coast of Normandy, France, at night.^[5]^[6] These demons were led by a masked, club-wielding giant and they were known as familia herlequin (var. familia herlethingi). This medieval French version of the Germanic Wild Hunt, Mesnée d'Hellequin, has been connected to the English figure of Herla cyning ('host-king'; German: Erlkönig).^[7]

The first known appearance on stage of Hellequin is dated to 1262, the character of a masked and hooded devil in Jeu da la Feuillière by Adam de la Halle, and it became a stock character in French passion plays.*

So, it seems the shadow side of clowns, jokers and tricksters has long been a part of our collective unconscious.

In utilising the clown image, Supernatural draws on all its historic associations while simultaneously connecting the Demon with the themes of deception, disguise and mask that have recurred throughout the season. Like the clown, demons can appear in disguise: by possessing humans, they are able to wear a borrowed face that masks their true form.

At the same time, it’s important to remember that the Winchesters also use deception and disguise to achieve their ends – a fact that has just been foregrounded in the previous scene. The difference, of course, is that they do it “for the greater good” . . . except, by the end of the season, we’ll see major cracks forming in the foundation beneath their moral high ground. Already, the show is starting to hint that the Winchesters aren’t as unlike the things they hunt as they, or we, would like to believe. In the next episode, the Demon itself will directly implicate Dean in the mask theme when it points out that he uses humour to “mask all that nasty pain” then proceeds to unmask some uncomfortable truths that lie beneath.

Here is another aspect that the show’s demons share with the clown tradition: in ironic juxtaposition with the oft-repeated mantra “demons lie”, the writers often use them to function as “truth tellers”. Their mind reading abilities coupled with their iconoclastic contempt for social niceties makes them uniquely qualified to confront the main characters with parts of themselves they’d rather not openly acknowledge. This duality is highlighted in season two when Jo asks the question “I know demons lie, but ... do they ever tell the truth too?” and Dean replies “sometimes, I guess. Especially if they know it'll mess with your head” [“Born Under a Bad Sign” (s2e14)]. The trick, of course, is to discern which is which. (I’ll talk about the "truth-teller" theme again when I review what we learn about the Winchesters in their confrontation with the Demon in the season one finale, “Devil’s Trap”.)

TBC.

*For more about the history of clowns, for anyone who’s interested, here are some of my sources:

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-weird-reason-were-afraid-of-clowns/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evil_clown
https://owlcation.com/social-sciences/a-brief-history-of-clowns-how-did-they-become-evil
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harlequin

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Mon, 08 Jun 2026 09:53:21 GMT

"Salvation" (cont.)

The previous scene ended with John revealing that signs of the Demon are gathering in Salvation, Iowa, and now we cut to a highway where we can see John’s truck approaching followed by the Impala.

Normally, when the Winchesters enter a new town, it's identified by a road sign that we're shown as the Impala passes it. This time, however, the town border is viewed from the opposite direction and, in place of the usual welcome sign, the camera crosses the road to focus instead on the one intended for those leaving Salvation, which seems portentous.

Also ominous is the question at the bottom: “Are you ready for Judgment Day?” with an apparent Biblical citation beneath that just happens to have the same initials as John . . . except there is no book in the Bible that has the abbreviation “JW”, so the innocent looking inscription is actually very pointed. Is it truly a message for John? If so, from whom? Or is it just the props department winking at the audience again? I can’t think of any particular significance for the chapter and verse cited; do the numbers 2.27 suggest anything to others? If they were chosen randomly, I can’t help feeling an opportunity was missed to have more fun with them: 1.21 for the episode number perhaps; or 2.1 for the episode when John could be said to face judgement; or even 2.22 . . .

But, to return to the plot, John pulls off the road and emerges from the truck looking very upset; he’s just heard the news of Jim Murphy’s death from his friend, Caleb, and traces of sulphur found at the scene indicate a demon was behind it.

DEAN
A demon. (JOHN nods) The Demon?
JOHN
I don't know. Could be he just got careless, he slipped up.
Maybe the demon knows we're getting close.
DEAN
What do we do?
JOHN
Now we act like every second counts.

There's two hospitals and a health centre in this county. We split up, cover more ground.

I want records. I want a list of every infant that's going to be six months old in the next week.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.21_Salvation_(transcript)

“Dad that could be dozens of kids,” Sam points out. “How do we know which one's the right one?”

“We check them all that's how,” John retorts but, when Sam still looks doubtful, he adds “You got any better ideas?” It’s an interesting change of approach from what we’ve seen of his behaviour up until now; it seems he’s taken on board the events of the previous episode and is now ready to treat his sons as equals and seek their input.

Unfortunately, they don’t, so he returns to the truck. But he pauses before getting in, overcome with emotion, attracting Dean’s concern:

DEAN
Dad?
JOHN
(upset) Yeah. It's Jim. You know, I can't....(his face hardens)
This ends, now. I'm ending it. I don't care what it takes.
(Ibid.)

As John climbs into the truck, the camera picks out Dean in the background, looking troubled, and he continues to watch his father while he gets into the Impala and slams the door after him.

Perhaps he’s concerned about the statement John’s just made and the lengths his father might be prepared to go to “end it now.” John may not care what it takes but, as we learn later, Dean does. There are limits to what he’s prepared to sacrifice for the sake of vengeance.

The next scene follows the investigation process, cutting from one Winchester to the next as they separate to their assigned destinations. As John pulls up outside a hospital, we see him searching for a suitable ID from a collection he keeps in the glove compartment . . .

It’s a nice little call back to the similar moment in the pilot when Dean proudly produces his own box of fake IDs.

S1e01

Ah, he used to enjoy hunting back then, didn't he? Things change.

At the reception desk of the second Salvation hospital, he notices an attractive young woman noticing him, and his response is true to form:

“Only I’m working right now,” he adds, with a tone and expression that seem genuinely regretful.

I think this might be a little more than just another needless reminder that Dean’s a hound dog. Over recent episodes we’ve seen indications that he has lost his enthusiasm for the job, so perhaps this scene is developing on that theme though, this close to catching up with the Demon, we might have expected him to be more hyped. But it’s possible he’s still concerned about his father’s words, “I don’t care what it takes”, and worried what this search could end up costing him – so maybe he really would prefer to be doing something else right now.

Meanwhile, Sam has been combing assiduously through birth records at the Salvation medical centre, but the real breakthrough in the case comes after he leaves . . .

. . . which I’ll talk about in another post, coming soon.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

"This Small Dark Place" by Roxymissrose - a fic rec.

fanspired — Fri, 05 Jun 2026 10:18:15 GMT

A decade in the making, one of the great stories of our fandom is now complete. roxymissrose has taken an old trope and transformed it into an insightful social examination that has become disturbingly relevant in our time. Everyone should read this who cares about freedom:

Read on AO3 archiveofourown.org/series/284478 or see the post below to find it on Live Journal.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Tue, 26 May 2026 08:58:52 GMT

"Salvation" (cont.)

Post title frame, the action moves to Manning Colorado where we left the Winchesters last episode. The scene opens with a shot of a deer head mounted on the cabin wall . . .

which establishes the setting as a hunting cabin, I guess. (Heh). It’s a visually striking image that ties back to the last frame of the previous scene, which focused on Pastor Jim’s wide staring eyes as he choked out his last breath. For me, it also conjures the association of “deer caught in headlights”, which seems like an ominous portent of where the Winchesters’ story might be headed.

The camera pans over the now familiar hunting storyboard cluttered with weather reports, ancient texts in ancient languages, images of demons from different cultures, a US map chequered with random crosses over Tennessee, South Carolina and Maryland (that, so far as I recall, are never explained), a note about “sulpher traces” (sic) . . . and a drawing we cannot fully appreciate on first watch:

While fire streaming from the window recalls the pilot, and the text surrounding the illustration makes reference to Mary’s death, there was no dark shadow framed in the fire that night. This picture only resonates on rewatch, after we’ve seen the end of this episode. Is it just a fun piece of foreshadowing thrown in by the set dressers? Or could it be a subtle hint that John also had some precognitive ability?

Then there’s this image, which is also never wholly explained but seems laden with suggestive significance:

The reference to the Colt is obvious, of course. Who Gerry may be, I don’t think we ever learn. More curious is the central figure, which seems deeply ambiguous. Scrawled in dark pen it looks possibly demonic, yet it has a halo that confers saintly or possibly angelic connotations. Traditionally, the symbol of the dark angel has been associated with the human struggle to navigate or embrace dualistic opposites: light and dark, good and evil, divine and demonic. [cf. https://www.christianwebsite.com/dark-angel-meaning/ ] In Jungian psychology it is associated with the shadow self: that rejected part of the psyche that is repressed, but which nevertheless informs all that a person does. [cf. https://angelsmorts.org/2026/03/24/jung-and-the-integration-of-the-shadow-angel/ ] The symbol can also be associated with the Angel of Death, so it seems notable that this figure has a deathlike claw that holds a mysterious glowing orb: an object of magical power? Or a human soul, perhaps?

And, most disturbingly, we see Sam’s name next to the figure – whether merely linked by association or intended as a label, we cannot know. His name is both ringed and squared, for double emphasis. Notably, these two shapes have also been assigned opposed traditional meanings: the circle being associated with divinity, the natural order, the feminine principle; the square with the human, the man-made, the masculine principle.

Amidst all these deep and ominous hints, the altering of the motel name on its stationery seems a frivolous and incongruous gag.

A shot of the bookcase is interesting too, most notably for the prominent placement of a book entitled Secrets. In a scene that is ostensibly all about revealing knowledge, could this be a hint that there are some secrets John is still concealing?

Do we believe him?

John explains that he first picked up the demon’s trail a year ago. “It must have come out of hiding, or hibernation,” he says.

JOHN
It starts in Arizona, then New Jersey, California. Houses burned down to the ground.
It's going after families, just like it went after us.
SAM
Families with infants?
JOHN
Yeah. The night of the kid's six-month birthday.
SAM
I was six months old that night?
JOHN
Exactly six months.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.21_Salvation_(transcript)

John doesn’t respond directly, but he looks shifty. He won’t make eye contact with Sam, and the way he’s hiding his mouth is a body language tell that can signal when someone is withholding information. This is the knowledge I believe he was hoping to spare Sam, because he knew the conclusion his son would draw from it, and he remains silent while the brothers argue over what it means.

SAM
So basically, this demon is going after these kids for some reason.
The same way it came for me? So Mom's death...Jessica. It's all because of me?

DEAN
We don't know that Sam.
SAM
Oh really? Cause I'd say we're pretty damn sure, Dean.

Everyone takes a breath and calms down.
(Ibid.)

Sam asks the pertinent question “so why's he doing it. What does he want?”

I suspect John knows more about that than he’s willing to let on. After all, in the season 2 premiere, he admits to Azazel that he’s known “the truth about Sammy” and the other children “for a while”. But, for now, he just says “I wish I had more answers, I do. I've always been one step behind it. Look, I've never gotten there in time to save . . . ”

He trails off into silence, and the brothers are also quiet for several moments. Perhaps they’re all thinking the same thing, that John particularly regrets failing to save Jessica.

To move past the awkward moment, Dean directs the conversation toward the practical question of how to find the demon and stop it before it strikes again, and John reveals that he’s identified signs that occurred before the attacks, and before Mary’s death and Jessica’s: “It took me a while to see the pattern,” he says, “but it's there in the days before these fires signs crop up in an area. Cattle deaths, temperature fluctuations, electrical storms.”

In the Supernatural season 1 companion, Nicholas Knight comments that these phenomena are “essentially the Earth itself balking at the demon’s unwelcome presence” (p.114), which I thought was an interesting observation.

And now, John reveals, these same signs are happening again . . . in Salvation, Iowa.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love from "Dead Man's Blood" (A Masterpost)

fanspired — Mon, 18 May 2026 07:31:16 GMT

"Nice gun." "Just the way Dad does it." "I was wrong."

"You were just p----d off you couldn't control me anymore!"

"Revenge isn't worth much if you end up dead." “Once a vampire has your scent, it's for life.”

Atonement with the Father "We're stronger as a family, Dad. We just are. You know it."

It works. "So, we go after this damn thing. Together."

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Sun, 17 May 2026 09:59:50 GMT

Supernatural, Season 1
Episode 21, “Salvation”
Written by: Sera Gamble and Raelle Tucker
Directed by: Robert Singer

Warning: image heavy post.

🎵Carry on, my wayward son.
There'll be peace when you are done.
Lay your weary head to rest.
Don't you cry no more. 🎵

Yes, for those who watched the original aired episode, or those who watched on DVD, this was the first time we heard the show’s unofficial theme song – “Wayward Son” by Kansas – playing over the season recap. Streamers, alas, will have to wait until the season 2 finale. For now, they get “Calling” by Soberskin.

Sammy in his crib, Mary on the ceiling, little Dean left holding the baby.
*Boom*.
“Dad’s missing.” “Saving people, hunting things” Jessica on the ceiling.
“You could be some kind of freak!” “They say this gun can kill anything.”
“I have these nightmares, and sometimes they come true”.
“I guess we are stronger as a family. We go after this damn thing. Together”.

For some reason, this opening and its location made a deep impression on me. Although it’s only one scene, I never forget where it took place . . . Of course, it was a rather memorable scene.

In a quiet, empty church, a kindly looking pastor is studying the Good Book . . .

when a draught blows through, disturbing the peace and the candles – which can’t be good . . .

Is it significant that the wind comes before the door opens?

Something else that isn't good.

Meg approaches the pastor and tells him she needs to talk, and begins by acknowledging she’s done some “not good things”. The pastor assures her “there’s always forgiveness for us if we seek it.”

It’s an interesting philosophical question. Can a demon be redeemed?

Perhaps optimists watching this episode for the first time wondered at this point if it were possible that Meg might have genuine regrets, might truly desire forgiveness. The pastor, it seems, is an optimist. “I like to say salvation was created for sinners,” he says. “Tell me what's on your mind,” and he listens patiently, impassively, kindly, as she lists her sins. His expression doesn’t change at all while she tells him of the many times she’s lied, stolen and lusted. He’s a pastor; he’s heard it all before. But then she adds one final detail:

MEG
And the other day I met this man. A nice guy, you know?
We had a really good chat, sort of like this....

That gets a reaction.

And so do we, finally. Well, we knew there was something off about Meg when she survived a seven storey drop in Chicago, but now we get the reveal that she’s a demon, and no ordinary demon apparently.

PASTOR
(Backing away) I know what you are. You can't be here. This is hallowed ground.
MEG
(Standing) Please. Maybe that works in the minor leagues. But not with me.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.21_Salvation_(transcript)

The Pastor runs out of the church, down some stairs and into a room beneath where he barricades the door with a heavy beam, then turns to an alcove arrayed with a strikingly familiar collection of weapons:

Clearly this is no ordinary pastor, either.

Meg demonstrates previously unrevealed power when she easily kicks open the door, snapping the wooden barricade, almost like it’s made of plywood or something . . .

Incidentally, observant viewers might notice an interesting detail about her attire. Last time we saw Meg, her jacket was yellow. Now it’s the colour of congealed blood. I confess, it wasn’t something I picked up on until I read in the Companion that it was a deliberate creative choice that the gradual reveal of Meg’s true power and nature should be reflected in her wardrobe.

Costume designer Diane Widas describes her sartorial evolution, from her first appearance where “they wanted her to look like she would be appealing, but without being overtly sexual . . . As she got stronger, the yellow jacket was one that we bought and made work for her. Then the little red jacket, as she became more demonic, was one that I designed and we built for her, and that was to reflect a little more of her power as she shifted.”

Supernatural: The Official Companion Season 1 (p.113)

I thought it was worth mentioning as another example of the degree of thought that was invested into every aspect show. Another comes from the props department in the form of the sigil-engraved blade the pastor reaches for to defend himself against Meg’s attack.

Is this a prototype of the famous demon-killing knife? When that first makes its appearance in season 3, Bobby says he’s never heard of such a thing before, but it seems the pastor thinks he may have something that’ll do the job. But we’ll never know since, as the sigil blade swipes toward her, Meg simply plucks it from the air.

Now Meg reveals her purpose, which is to find the Winchesters. The pastor is her means to that end but, alas, not in the way he thinks:

PASTOR
I haven't spoken to John Winchester in over a year. You're wasting your time.
Even if I did know where they were, I'd never tell you.
MEG
I know.
MEG slits his throat with his own knife. He falls back into a chair, gasping, then dying.
MEG smiles and walks away.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.21_Salvation_(transcript)

So, his end was forewarned in Meg’s story of the nice man with whom she had a “really good chat, sort of like this”.

Kudos to the practical FX team, btw. (Ew.)

Farewell, Pastor Jim. We hardly knew ye 😢

His name hasn’t been confirmed yet, of course, but we can probably guess from the revelation that he’s John’s friend, and Pastor Jim was mentioned in “Something Wicked”.

In The Companion, Sera Gamble reveals that she particularly wrote Jim and Caleb into this episode because she wanted to “meet” the friends that had been mentioned throughout the season, but says she did it knowing that Eric would only allow it if they died instantly. (p.110) A pity, because I found Jim an interesting character and I would have liked to see more of him. Perhaps there might have been potential for childhood flashbacks in season 2 if Bobby had not become such a fan favourite. Since Jim clearly babysat the boys on occasion, it seems plausible he might have been the religious influence that inspired the faith in angels and daily prayers that Sam reveals in season 2. But once Bobby was established as the boys’ mentor figure, I guess Jim’s role was moot. Nevertheless, kudos to actor Richard Sali who was immediately engaging in his brief appearance.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Mon, 04 May 2026 08:08:39 GMT

"Dead Man's Blood"

Back in the cabin, the boys are packing up when John walks in. He opens with a statement that initially appears like he’s still trying to be their drill sergeant.

But his body language and tone are inconsistent with the image of a CO barking orders. Instead, he saunters in with his hands his pockets and delivers the words in a casual, unconfrontational manner that belies their supposed intent.

The brothers’ responses are an interesting reversal on their usual positions. Now Sam is all “yes, sir,” while Dean is the one challenging his father.

There’s a pause filled with subtle little physical gestures that emphasize the tension as everyone waits to see how the scene will play out. John turns a steady gaze on Dean almost like he’s waiting to see if the boy will back down, but he doesn’t. Dean swallows but meets his father’s gaze and stands his ground.

Meanwhile Sam side-eyes his brother with an alarmed little double take that seems to suggest that, while he’s been confronting John all episode, he’s afraid that Dean doing it might just end the world as they know it. And, in a way, it does:

It’s a nice piece of dramatic symmetry that this episode has been bookended by John saying, “I was wrong” in the early scenes and now “You’re right,” in the epilogue. It signals that he is finally ready to accept his sons as adults and equals as we move into the climax of the season.

JOHN
It scares the hell out of me. You two are all I've got.
But I guess we are stronger as a family.
So . . . we go after this damn thing. Together.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

And there’s pride and satisfaction in both the brothers’ faces as they prepare for their final fight as a family . . .

And thus, “The Atonement with the Father” is completed . . . for now. The theme will be revisited in a darker form in the season finale.

Incidentally, at the end of the episode, the opening bars of the show’s main theme plays across the closing moments of this scene. To the best of my recollection, it was the only time either of the closing credits themes ever appeared in the main body of the show. And, as the actual credits play, I think it may be the last time we hear the full unedited version of the theme with its original introductory riff. It was my favourite version of the theme, but from season 2 onwards we get an edited arrangement that skips that opening flourish. I was sorry to see it go.

One final note on “Dead Man’s Blood”: I’m not adamant about this, but y’all know how I like to look for double meanings in episode titles, and I can’t help wondering if the “dead man” in this one is a foreshadowing of John’s ultimate fate. And his “blood”? Why, that would be his family – his sons who have now ‘come of age’ and are ready to fully inherit ‘the family business’ and continue his legacy. What do you think? Too much of a stretch?

Coming soon: Scenes I love from “Salvation”.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Tue, 28 Apr 2026 05:16:59 GMT

"Dead Man's Blood" (cont.)

Warning: image heavy post

By this time the pack have discovered the body of their fallen comrade and they’re very upset about it. “They cut off Hank’s head!” Beau tells Luther. It’s noticeable that the writers are taking care to make sure we know the names of these vampires. It’s a device that personalizes them and encourages the audience to identify with them as people, not just monsters. Luther’s anxiety when he learns Kate is missing is evident. We’re getting a clear picture that they do indeed act like a family, with strong feelings for each other. While they’re deciding what to do, Luther hears a truck on the highway some distance away. “Kate’s in that truck,” he says with conviction. Either the skunk cabbage isn’t entirely effective, or the strength of their bond confers some kind of 6^th sense that reveals her whereabouts.

The pack set off in pursuit of John, leaving Beau behind to guard the nest. Big mistake.

Maybe that 6^th sense is operating again because he seems uneasy. But it seems the cabbage is doing its job since, although he starts checking around the barn for the source of his misgivings, he doesn’t pinpoint it until it’s too late.

It’s a nice little monster-as-victim scene that subverts the more familiar horror movie tropes. Seeing this from Beau’s pov after the previous scene where we were admitted into the group and encouraged to sympathize with their grief over the loss of their comrade, it almost starts to feel like Dean’s the monster in the scenario . . .

Until we’re reminded that he’s here to save the vampires’ victims.

What I find surprising is that Dean was able to sneak up right behind Beau without being heard. True, there hasn’t been any obvious focus on vampire hearing in the episode but in season 3, “Fresh Blood”, we ‘re told they can “hear a heart beating from half a block away.” Another of those inconsistencies, I guess.

Another fun fact from the Supernatural Then and Now podcast: AD Kevin Parks described the process for the beheading effects. It was complicated but, as I understood it, they used two takes: one with the vampire in shot where they filmed the Winchesters swing up for the stroke; then another with the vampire removed for the full swipe; then VFX spliced the two takes together in post-production. Parks praised J3 for their ability to repeat the exact same arm motions for these shots so the merge could be achieved convincingly.

Here’s another visual effect that I loved. Reversing the trend from the previous scenes where the vampire pov made them seem more human, we now see a shot from John’s pov that clearly frames them as animals:

That flashing eyes effect was absent from later vampire episodes but, thinking about it, that may have been deliberate since later seasons tended to continue the trend of humanizing the monsters whilst increasingly ‘monsterfying’ the Winchesters.

With Kate as hostage, John coerces Luther into placing the Colt on the ground between them. I’m not sure what John would have done if Luther just didn’t happen to bring it with him but, luckily, he did. Not so fortunately, while he’s distracted picking up the gun, John doesn’t notice that Kate has managed to loosen the ties round her wrists. “It’s a nice move,” Luther remarks, “you almost made it.” Kate breaks free, smashes her elbow back into John, and Luther finishes her work by punching and flinging him back against the truck, knocking him out. The windscreen smashes sending shattered glass flying everywhere.

The stunt work is really effective. I’m assuming they just threw a bunch of sugar glass granules at JDM as he dropped backwards, but I’m still going to give him kudos for not reacting when pieces wind up on his mouth.

Just when we’re sure John is done for – (As if. He’s practically a main character; he’s never gonna die, right?) – there’s a whooshing sound and one of the few unnamed vampires gets a gutful of arrow and then we get a shot of the brothers running through the woods armed with crossbows.

The cavalry has arrived!

Unfortunately, their sortie is short lived as Luther manages to grab Sam, and get him in the now familiar choke-hold trope. I see complaints on some fansites that this happens too often in the show, but the ubiquitous restriction of Sam's breath is important symbolically, since the breath is traditionally associated with soul and Sam represents the soul half of the brothers’ heart/soul partnership. Later this season, we'll see a companion scene where Dean's heart is attacked. The frequent repetition of the trope helps to emphasize the import of its dramatic reversal in the moment at the end of season four when Sam chokes Dean.

Dean hesitates for a half a heartbeat. Perhaps a practical side of him is weighing up the probability that, once he gives up his weapon, the vampires will kill them all anyway but, of course, it’s Sam, so practical doesn’t really enter into it.

This is the point where, in the earlier script, Luther invites the brothers to join his pack:

https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood#Trivia_&_References

It’s a moment that continues to emphasize the parallels between the vampires and the Winchesters, and hints at something vampiric in the Winchester family dynamic. John is being likened to Luther. It’s already been pointed up that Luther lost his family to a hunter, as John lost his wife to the Demon. Luther wanting to recruit the brothers points up that they are John’s pack. In recruiting them for his hunting mission he might be considered to be sucking the life out of his sons, in the sense that he has deprived them of the normal lives they might have had, just as Luther has robbed his minions of their former lives.

Ultimately, though, the writers decided to go another way that, while still comparing the vampires to the Winchesters, continues the theme of victimhood from the previous scene:

LUTHER
You people. Why can't you just leave us alone. We have as much right to live as you do.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

It’s a statement that might invite the audience to consider whether vampires are truly evil just because they feed off humans to survive? Is that essentially any different than humans eating the meat of other animals? The point is made more overtly in season two when Lenore makes reference to the “food chain”. [s2e02 “Bloodlust”.]

Food for thought 😉

But, to return to the current episode:

JOHN
(from behind) I don't think so.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

Luther turns to find himself staring down the barrel of the Colt. As do we:

Then, in a beautiful SloMo effect that distinctly foreshadows the season 2 finale, we watch the bullet sail across the scene . . .

. . . to bullseye Luther’s forehead.

Pretty cool, huh? But still a mere dress rehearsal for what the FX team come up with for “All Hell Breaks Loose”.

Again, the earlier script gives us an insight into the journey from initial idea to execution:

https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood#Trivia_&_References

Luther in the aired episode doesn’t dissolve. I’m guessing that was dismissed because it was far too “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” for a Supernatural episode. Instead, an inner explosion appears to illuminate him from within and, in a call back to his opening entrance, his final moments are bathed in a halo of light from his car’s headlamps.

It almost seems like an image of martyrdom. And perhaps it is, in a sense, because Luther is really just an unfortunate pawn in John’s grand plan. I mean, sure, he’s a vampire so John wants him dead (although he makes no effort to stop Kate and Jenny from escaping), and he was threatening Sam, so John absolutely wants to save his son but . . . first and foremost – and, yes, I’m afraid I do believe it was the motive uppermost in his mind – he wants to test the gun.

Hence the quiet smile of satisfaction that steals onto his features when he sees his guinea pig finally lying dead in the dirt.

It works.

I wonder if he would still have smiled quite so complacently if he’d known the eventual cost of letting those last two vampires get away . . . (IYKYK)

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Mon, 20 Apr 2026 08:23:48 GMT

"Dead Man's Blood" (cont.)

A/N: I've been having trouble getting LJ to accept this post so I've broken it in two to see if that helps. This is the second of 2 parts. The first can be found here.

In the following scene the Winchesters are by a campfire, preparing themselves for an upcoming venture by rubbing themselves with the ashes of burned saffron, skunk's cabbage and trillium, which John explains will mask their scent. Another piece of lore that, so far as I know, is SPN specific.

Perhaps because he was denied the opportunity to behead stunt vampire number 2, Sam is back to questioning his father: "You sure they'll come after her?" he asks.

JOHN
Yeah. Vampires mate for life. She means more to the leader than the gun.
But the blood sickness is going to wear off soon, so you don't have a lot of time.
SAM
A half hour oughta do it.
JOHN
And then I want you out of the area as fast as you can.
SAM
But...
DEAN
Well, Dad you can't take care of them all yourself.
JOHN
I'll have her. And the Colt.
SAM
But after. We're gonna meet up, right? Use the gun together. Right?
Long pause.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

It becomes apparent that John intends to go after the Demon and leave both of his sons out of the fight. When Sam berates his father for treating them like children, John retorts “You are my children. I'm trying to keep you safe.” And, notably, Dean is now making objections too: "Dad, all due respect, but that's a bunch of crap." he says, eliciting a stunned response from both Sam and John.

JOHN
Excuse me?
DEAN
You know what Sammy and I have been hunting. Hell, you sent us on a few hunting trips yourself.
You can't be that worried about keeping us safe . . .
. . . I think maybe Sammy's right about this one. We should do this together.
SAM nods.
DEAN
We're stronger as a family, Dad. We just are. You know it.
(Ibid.)

This is the companion scene to the “Atonement with the Father” we witnessed between Sam and John earlier, but now it’s from Dean’s perspective. Perhaps encouraged by Sam’s challenge to their father's authority and seeing that John (to a degree) accepted and respected it, he steps up to the plate himself. Like the Twin Warriors of the Navaho who survived the test of their father’s ordeals (Campbell, op. cit. previous post) he and Sam have passed through the “Road of Trials” (Campbell, p.81), the mission that John set them on, and now Dean recognizes that entitles him to a voice, and to be acknowledged as his father’s equal.

But it seems John is not yet ready to acknowledge his sons as adults on an equal par with himself.

JOHN
We're running out of time. You do your job and you get out of the area. That's an order.
Dean looks down, emotional. Sam clenches his jaw.
(Ibid).

I do think, however, that there’s a little more to John’s perspective than we’re shown overtly, and it’s something we can only really appreciate with hindsight.

It’s telling that when Dean cites the hunts he and Sam have already faced as evidence of their readiness to be included in the big fight with the Demon, John responds, “It's not the same thing,” and, although he uses the excuse that the Demon is “a bad son of a bitch” and he’s trying to keep them safe, I suspect it’s more than that. John’s crusade is essentially different in nature from the mission he passed to his sons. Whereas he has tasked them with the supposedly heroic pursuit of “saving people, hunting things”, his object is the quest for revenge, and I believe his hope was always to save them from the taint of that darker motive. Furthermore, I think it’s likely John already has some concept of the cosmic scale of the fight he’s waging and while his sons ‘fight the good fight’, he wishes to keep them out of the War. Had he succeeded, if Sam and Dean had simply stuck to the mundane task of battling monsters and never involved themselves in the wars of Heaven and Hell, all might have been well. But, given who the Winchesters are, and the enormity of the forces stacked against them, we know that was never in their cards.

And, of course, there’s one more thing that John knows that he isn’t telling, and he has good reason to want to keep Sam and the Demon apart . . . but that’s a discussion for another episode . . .

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Sun, 19 Apr 2026 08:27:08 GMT

"Dead Man's Blood" (cont.)

A/N: I've been having trouble getting LJ to accept this post so I'm trying breaking it in two to see if that helps. This is the first of 2 parts. The rest will follow shortly.

In my last post, I referred to the ongoing themes of vampirism and cannibalism in the series becoming a metaphor for the ways in which the Winchester family feed off each other. At the end of that scene, when Dean presents a jar of blood to John, he sets it back down in front of his sons and tells them, “You know what to do”. It seems significant that blood is the linking object between that scene and the next – which opens with Dean out on the road, seemingly tinkering with the engine of the Impala.

But it soon becomes clear that he’s making himself bait to draw out the vampires.

John’s earlier comment indicated Dean knew his role in the plan without his father having to say it. This strikes me as an echo of the scene from “Wendigo” where Dean and Sam both knew without having to verbalize it that Dean intended to use himself as bait to draw the monster away from the family.

I feel there's a disturbing implication here that Dean is expected to risk his life in this way so routinely that it goes without saying. It’s an illustration of just one of the ways in which John’s obsession with hunting – his bloodlust, if you will – could be said to be draining the life of his sons.

With a pun that’s definitely intended, Kate threatens to make Dean into a vampire. In an early draft of the script*, Luther later made the same offer to both brothers as a reward, because he was impressed with their fighting spirit. The fact that the vampires appear to see the Winchesters as kindred spirits is another way in which the show draws a parallel between the hunters and the creatures they hunt, and – deliberate or not – it foreshadows Sam’s actual blood dependency in later seasons.

*https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood#Trivia_&_References

So, it isn’t just Sam who gets violated by the demons and monsters. And it probably isn’t an accident that the themes of vampirism and violation coincide in this episode. But Kate’s non-consensual face-suck is interrupted when she is herself penetrated . . . by the shaft of an arrow through her chest.

So, Dean’s words to Sam in “Bugs” have proven to be prophetic:

S1e08: “Bugs.”

I love the way show drops these seemingly insignificant details that turn out to be important later. 😁

Kate brags that the arrow “barely even stings” but, of course, it’s coated in “dead man’s blood”, and she soon succumbs to its effects. “Load her up,” John instructs Dean “I’ll take care of this one,” meaning a second vampire that Sam was totally just about to decapitate himself, and he doesn’t seem happy about being bumped from the task.

It seems, despite their recent talk, John’s still keeping him sitting on the barrel.

Please click here to continue.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Mon, 13 Apr 2026 10:33:45 GMT

Dead Man's Blood (cont.)

The Atonement with the Father (Part 1)

Many will remember the famous scene from The Empire Strikes Back where the hero, Luke Skywalker, fights Darth Vader, the villain he believes to have killed his father, only to receive the shocking revelation: “No. I am your father.” The character arc that follows is a modern rendering of a trope as old as storytelling itself, one that Joseph Campbell has described as “The Atonement with the Father”, a pivotal moment in the perennial Hero Myth.

Luke survives the fight at the cost of his hand, which is subsequently replaced with a mechanical prosthetic. In Return of the Jedi, a vision quest reveals he is haunted by the fear of becoming a syntheticized monster like his father. Afterward, Luke has an opportunity to confront the ghost of his old mentor, Obi Wan (Ben) Kenobi, whom he berates for having concealed the truth from him:

LUKE
You told me Vader betrayed and murdered my father.

BEN
You father was seduced by the dark side of the Force.
He ceased to be Anakin Skywalker and became Darth Vader.
When that happened, the good man who was your father was destroyed.
So, what I have told you was true... from a certain point of view.

LUKE (turning away, derisive)
A certain point of view!

BEN
Luke, you're going to find that many of the truths we cling to
depend greatly on our own point of view.
https://imsdb.com/scripts/Star-Wars-Return-of-the-Jedi.html

Kripke has acknowledged the influence of Campbell's work on the devopment of the Supernatural story. The seminal book The Hero with a Thousand Faces, is a compilation of heroic tales, drawn from a wide range of different cultures and times, that all tend to share common elements. In many of these stories the hero (or heroes – sometimes there two, often brothers) undertakes two quests: he must defeat a great ogre whilst simultaneously seeking his father. His journey requires him to undergo a series of trials before he is ready to perceive the true face of the Father. One example that Campbell describes is that of the Twin Warriors of the Navaho who, having been given charms and protections by the Spider Woman (the Mother Goddess) seek an audience with the Sun God. After surviving a series of ordeals that the god puts them through, they are acknowledged by him as his sons. (pp.110-111.)

Campbell explains how the ordeals prepare the hero for the revelation. Through completing the trials, he comes to a better understanding of the nature of his reality and, having done so, Father and Tyrant are ultimately revealed to be different aspects of the same being.

In “Dead Man’s Blood” and, indeed, the following two episodes, Supernatural explores this same trope from the Hero’s Journey. I believe Kripke’s treatment of the monomyth is ultimately more complex than the version seen in Star Wars, nevertheless both draw on that common theme of the importance of point of view.

In the following scene from “Dead Man’s Blood”, we have a rare opportunity to appreciate John’s perspective.

It opens in a cabin where Sam is impatiently pacing back and forth, waiting for Dean to return from the assigned errand. He very much resembles a caged lion, or one of Yann Martel’s “cantankerous” beta animals “sitting on their colourful barrels on the edge of the ring” excluded from the main show.

Those are definitely his "brooding and pensive" shoulders 😉

“It shouldn't be taking this long. I should go help,” Sam grouses.

“Dean’s got it,” John assures him.

But Sam continues to pace, so John decides to distract him with an anecdote that proves to be highly illuminating.

Remember that phrase. We’ll hear a disturbing echo of it before the end of the season.

John reveals that when Sam was born, he opened a savings account for him with a deposit of $100:

JOHN
I did the same thing for your brother. It was a college fund. And every month I'd put in another hundred dollars, until...
Anyway, my point is, Sam, this is never the life that I wanted for you.
SAM
Then why'd you get so mad when I left?
JOHN
You gotta understand something. After your mother passed, all I saw was evil, everywhere.
And all I cared about was keeping you boys alive. I wanted you...prepared. Ready.
Except somewhere along the line, I ... uh ... I stopped being your father and I ... I became your, your drill sergeant.*
So, when you said that you wanted to go away to school, all I could think about,
my only thought was, that you were gonna be alone. Vulnerable.
(Ibid.)

*This apologia is convincingly elaborated in John Winchester’s Journal, a book by Alex Irvine. Narrated from John’s point of view, it begins from the famous line “I went to Missouri and learned the truth” and gives a believable and canonically plausible account of John’s fall from the normal loving father we see in season 5, “The Song Remains the Same” to the obsessed hunter dramatized in season one. I recommend it as an enjoyable companion to the story we’re shown on screen, offering a somewhat more sympathetic perspective for some of John’s choices. I found it helped to reframe him as a victim of circumstance as much as his sons.

John continues: “Sammy, it just... it never occurred to me what you wanted. I just couldn't accept the fact that you and me -- We're just different.”

Sam huffs a laugh.
JOHN
What?
SAM
We're not different. Not anymore. With what happened to Mom and Jess... (laughs)
Well, we probably have a lot more in common than just about anyone.
JOHN
I guess you're right, son. (smiles)
(Ibid.)

I love Jared’s performance here. While smiling at the tragic irony he’s expressing, his micro-expressions simultaneously convey the lingering pain and grief still present beneath the smile:

In citing examples of the dual aspect of the Father, Campbell also references the two faces of the Biblical God, that of Wrath and that of unconditional Love and Mercy, often associated respectively with the Old and New Testaments. The challenge for Christianity is to reconcile these two paradoxical aspects of its one God.

Campbell casts this through the lens of Freudian/Jungian psychology, explaining the paradox as a projection of the self: “the ogre aspect of the father is a reflex of the victim’s own ego” he says, explaining that the spectre of parental disapproval keeps the child steeped in a sense of sin that prevents the adult from “a better balanced more realistic view of the father and therewith the world. Atonement (at-one-ment) consists in no more than the abandonment of that self-generated monster – the dragon thought to be God (superego) and the dragon thought to be Sin (repressed Id). But that requires an abandonment of the attachment to ego itself and that is what is difficult.” (Op. cit. pp.107-110)

Previous episodes have hinted that Sam’s conflict with his father has been rooted in a sense of never having been good enough him:

S1e08: “Bugs.”

But after his ordeal with Jessica, and having been through the trials of hunting with Dean, he is now able to see his father’s actions from a fresh perspective. And once John acknowledges his shortcomings as a father, they can both also acknowledge what they have in common (at-one-ment).

After a pause, Sam asks:

SAM
Hey Dad? Whatever happened to that college fund?
JOHN
Spent it on ammo.
They look at each other. SAM cracks up and so does JOHN.
(Ibid.)

It’s so refreshing at this point to see both father and son laughing together with genuine warmth.

The moment is brief, however – a mere glimmer of light in the darkness - and this is not the conclusion but just the beginning of Kripke's treatment of the atonement theme.

Another significant aspect of Campbell’s chapter on the Atonement is the reflections he sees of the hero myth in the initiation rites of young men in some tribal cultures. In describing the twin faces of the Ogre/Father, he notes that the aspect of unconditional love is sometimes represented by the Mother. In these stories, the mother’s domain is associated with childhood but, when the son enters the sphere of action, he enters the domain of the father. The ordeals of the initiation are designed to test the boy’s readiness to enter the adult realm and prove himself equal with the father. Interestingly, the chapter includes examples that contain elements of cannibalism. The boys of the Murngin tribe, for example, undergo a circumcision rite in which their foreskins are “eaten” by the Great Father Snake (p.117)

Again, Campbell analyses these rites in psychological terms:

“The native mythologies teach that the first initiation rites were carried out in such a way that all the young men were killed. The ritual is thus shown to be a dramatized expression of the Oedipal aggression of the elder generation and the circumcision a mitigated castration . . . But the rites provide also for the cannibal, patricidal impulse of the younger, rising group of males . . . for during the long period of symbolical instruction, there is a time when the initiates are forced to live only on the fresh-drawn blood of the older men.” (p.118) In former times, he continues “a man was killed for the purpose and portions of his body were eaten . . . Here we come as near a ritual representation of the killing and eating of the primal Father as we can get.” (p.119) He goes on to note the recurrence of these themes in the vegetation myths of the annual killing and resurrection of the god in diverse cultures all over the world, from the tragedies of Adonis, Attis, Osiris etc. even to the Christian concepts of Fall and Redemption, Crucifixion and Resurrection, and the symbolism of baptism and rebirth, and the drinking and eating of the body and blood of Christ in the Eucharist. (p.120).

We can see these concepts echoed in the actions of the vampires in the previous scene who fed off the blood of their victims, but then inducted the new vampire into the pack by feeding her the blood of a tribe member (the female vampire, Kate.)

While we see the ritual enacted literally in the vampire family, vampirism and cannibalism remain ongoing themes in the series, and a metaphor for the ways in which the Winchester family feed off each other.

So, I’m sure it’s no accident that the scene between John and Sam ends when Dean inserts a jar of blood between them. And there’s conscious irony in the knowledge that this is blood that has been extracted not from a living donor, but from dead bodies - and the revelation it is used not to sustain life, but to sap whatever passes for a vampire’s life force.

The wholesome moment between Sam and his father is over, and it’s back to business.

We will soon learn that what Dean knows is that it’s time for him to make himself bait to attract the vampires.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Wed, 08 Apr 2026 10:40:35 GMT

"Dead Man's Blood" (cont.)

As the Winchesters quietly drop into the barn through an upper-level hatch, we get our first sight of the vampires sleeping arrangement, and the show adds yet another innovation in the form of burlap hammocks which, as set decorator George Neuman notes are “much easier to travel around with than coffins.” (The Supernatural Official Season 1 Companion p.109)

The show does a great job of creating tension as the Winchesters creep around between the sleeping vampires. Apparently, they sleep very soundly, however, not waking even when Dean bumps into one of the hammocks.

Oops!

Or when the brothers try to rescue the victims.

Finding a group of victims locked in a cage, Dean dismisses trying to break a padlock, using a hook to lever off a hinge instead. The noise stirs the vampires but doesn’t wake them.

Meanwhile, John has found a separate room where Luther and Kate are sleeping, and sees the Colt holstered over their bedstead.

Inching toward it, he almost has it when shit hits the fan.

As Sam tries to untie the girl from the pole she begins to stir. “Hey. Hey hey, shh, I'm here to help you,” he whispers, but now fully awake, she screams, a feral roar that succeeds in finally rousing all the vampires.

Waking to find John, Luther flings him clear across the room, demonstrating vampiric strength that doesn’t always seem so evident in later seasons.

Quick thinking, John picks up a bottle and flings it through the blackened window, shattering it.

Now we see where Dean gets his renowned ability to utilise anything at hand as a weapon. 😁

“Abort! Abort!” John yells, and the brothers make a dash for it out of the barn and up the hill, stopping to look back and call for their father. Tense moments pass before he finally appears. “They won't follow. They'll wait till tonight,” he assures the brothers. “Once a vampire has your scent, it's for life.”

Portentous words, it turns out. (IYKYK 😬)

DEAN
Well what the hell do we do now?
JOHN
You gotta find the nearest funeral home, that's what.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

Dean pulls his head back in a double take, and the brothers at each other, mystified.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Wed, 01 Apr 2026 10:43:43 GMT

"Dead Man's Blood" (cont.)

Warning: image heavy post.

Meanwhile, the vampires have the young couple tied up in a barn and are partying it up while waiting for their leader to show up and, when he does, he makes an impressive figure , framed in the halo of car headlights as he makes his grand entrance through the big barn doors.

It’s a beautiful shot that subtly foreshadows his final scene at the end of the episode.

The woman vampire identifies herself as his mate by leaping into his arms before presenting the young couple for his inspection. He thinks the girl is “interesting” but quickly decides the boy fashion victim is good for nothing more than a snack for his minions, a cautionary tale of how a sense of style is so important 😉

While the rest of the pack chow down, the vampire lovers (Luther and Kate) move over to a table covered with the haul from Elkins’ cabin. Kate reveals proudly that she “made (Elkins) suffer” thinking this will please her mate since it seems Elkins was responsible for the deaths of his “family”. The information that the vampires have a sense of family humanizes them and mirrors John’s loss of his wife to the demon with Luther losing his family to a hunter. Unlike John, however, it appears Luther has learned to live with his loss, and his response to Kate’s news isn’t what she’d hoped. “You shouldn't have done that,” he tells her. “There's others like him. They'll know the signs and come looking for us. We have to be careful.”

Perhaps John could learn something from Luther’s pragmatism. Significantly, his sentiments are echoed by Dean in the very next episode:

“Salvation” s1e21

Luther is drawn to the Colt, and there’s some nice dramatic symmetry as Kate observes that it was made around the time of his birth. She mocks Elkins for thinking a gun could kill vampires, but Luther is more aware of its significance than she is:

By now, the audience might just be beginning to get a very slight glimmer of an idea that there's possibly something a bit special about this gun 😉

In the next scene, the vampires are making out while the girl victim awkwardly watches.

There’s a subtle thematic thread that links this overtly voyeuristic scene back to the earlier one where we were shown the brothers sleeping, and also to the wider reputation vampires have for watching young women while they’re sleeping in their beds – a habit that will be explicitly referred to as “rapey” in another vampire episode in season six (“Live Free or Twi-hard”).

The foreplay degenerates into blood-play, and we learn how new vampires are made as Luther cuts Kate’s wrist and she subsequently sucks her own blood and feeds it to the helpless victim in a non-con kissing session.

“Welcome home baby,” Luther says as the girl succumbs to the blood’s influence.

The thing that’s always puzzled me about the vampiric reproduction process as it’s represented on the show is this: if it’s that easy to make new vampires, why are they going extinct? Hunters could never kill them fast enough to stop the population growth if they just applied themselves a little – a point that’s addressed in season 6, I guess, but why did they have to wait for an alpha vampire to get involved to figure out just how quickly they could go forth and multiply? 🤔

The next morning Luther hustles a latecomer into the barn while the Winchesters watch from some distant bushes.

DEAN
(Hiding in the trees with JOHN and SAM) Son of a bitch. So they're really not afraid of the sun?
JOHN
Ahh, direct sunlight hurts like a nasty sunburn. The only way to kill 'em is by beheading.
And yeah, they sleep during the day -- doesn't mean they won't wake up.
DEAN
So I guess walking right in's not our best option.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

But John's answer defeats Dean's expectation:

I love the quiet relish in his tone (and in his eyes)😁

Moving back to the truck, he unpacks his trunk and reveals his equivalent of the brothers’ weapons cache: pristine and ultra-organized, it’s a sharp contrast to the cluttered collection we’ve seen in the Impala.

But, down the track, we will see Sam hunting with a very similar collection, hinting at how like his father Sam becomes when he loses his brother’s influence:

S3e11 “Mystery Spot”

Dean holds up a spare machete and offers it to his father, doubtless hoping it’ll demonstrate his boy scout preparedness . . .

But his offer is redundant since John has his own.

And when he sees his father’s imposing weapon, Dean’s own much smaller offering droops sadly in his hand.

The gag is managed with aplomb thanks to the actors’ understated delivery, and it provides a little comic relief before shit starts to get real.

Now that sufficient time has passed for tempers to cool since the earlier confrontation, John unexpectedly brings up the subject of the gun: “So, you boys really wanna know about this Colt?” he asks, casually, as if they’d expressed no more than a passing interest in it. Then he proceeds to recount the legend of how the gun was made:

Back in 1835, when Halley's comet was overhead, the same night those men died at the Alamo, they say Samuel Colt made a gun. A special gun. He made it for a hunter, a man like us only on horseback. Story goes he made thirteen bullets, and this hunter used the gun a half dozen times before he disappeared, the gun along with him. And somehow Daniel got his hands on it. (Ibid).

In the Then and Now podcast interview with Assistant Director Kevin Parks, it was revealed that this speech was originally just exposition with John simply conveying the information to his sons, but it was realized in post-production that the scene was too static so Kevin asked his wife, camera operator Jill McLaughlin, to come in especially to film a montage sequence to accompany John’s monologue. Smart move. It’s hard to imagine the story without the beautiful, detailed images of the Colt that illustrated it. And, honestly, it would have been such a shame if we’d never been able to see close up the magnificent craftwork the props department put into the weapon. Kudos to props, and to Kevin and Jill for their wonderful teamwork on this sequence.

After the montage, John concludes:

JOHN
They say... they say this gun can kill anything.
DEAN
Kill anything like, supernatural anything?
SAM
Like the demon.
JOHN
Yeah, the demon. Ever since I picked up its trail, I've been looking for a way to destroy that thing. Find the gun -- we may have it.
(Ibid.)

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Wed, 25 Mar 2026 09:13:31 GMT

"Dead Man's Blood" (cont.)

Warning: image heavy post.

The next scene begins in a motel room where the camera pans over the brothers in their beds. The show was always happy to exploit the sex appeal of its leads, and in the early seasons this often took the form of voyeuristic panning shots of them while they were sleeping. I’ve remarked before that the show seemed to be consciously subverting the traditional “male gaze” trope by objectifying male characters in a way that was unusual at the time. Down the track the scripts started to emphasize the creep factor of watching somebody while they’re sleeping so perhaps these early scenes were a deliberate choice to compromise the viewer in the act of invasive voyeurism even before it became an obvious recurring theme.

John, however, is not sleeping. When the camera comes to rest on his figure he is hunched over a hand radio, listening to a police report of a “possible 207”, which apparently refers to a kidnapping. He concludes it’s the vampires and hastens to rouse his sons. Sam is immediately questioning: “How do you know?” he asks. In similar circumstances he would probably have expected Dean to fill him in on the way to the car, but John’s response is impatient and dismissive: “Just follow me, OK?” He promptly exits with Sam dogging his steps, and a still sleepy Dean trailing in the rear.

This is our first opportunity to watch all the Winchesters working a hunt together, and the next few scenes are highly revealing of the family pack dynamics. They are also pivotal to how the dominoes fall, not only as we head toward the season finale, but also going forward into season two and beyond.

At the crime scene, John continues to exclude the boys from his investigation and Sam’s frustration is growing as a consequence:

EXTERIOR. DAY.
JOHN finishes talking to a cop on the scene and starts walking back to the boys, waiting by the Impala.
SAM
I don't see why we couldn't have gone over with him.
DEAN
Oh don't tell me it's already starting.
SAM
What's starting?
DEAN
(To John) What have you got?
JOHN
It was them all right. Looks like they're heading west. We'll have to double back to get around that detour.
SAM
How can you be so sure?
DEAN
Sam...
SAM
(Sharply to Dean) I just wanna know we're going in the right direction.
JOHN
We are.
SAM
How do you know?
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

Relenting a little, John produces his evidence:

“It's a vampire fang,” Dean exclaims as he hands it over, but John corrects him.

It’s another way in which the show differentiates itself from other vampire depictions but, despite John’s insistence and the fact that the FX crew continues to visualize vampiric teeth mostly consistently in future episodes, all subsequent scripts still tend to refer to them as fangs.

“Any more questions?” John demands and, when Sam remains silent, he snaps “all right, let's get out of here, we're losing daylight.” But, as they head for their cars, he adds an aside that clearly establishes the family pecking order:

JOHN
Hey Dean why don't you touch up your car before you get rust?
I wouldn't have given you the damn thing if I thought you were going to ruin it.
DEAN looks down at his car. SAM looks at DEAN with a 'told you so' look on his face. DEAN grimaces.
(Ibid.)

It seems that, having capitulated somewhat to Sam, John feels the need to reassert his authority by picking on Dean. It’s a particularly vicious swipe given how proud Dean is of the car. I think this is also the first time that we learn that John gave it to him, and the information adds another layer to its significance as a symbol of John’s love for and trust in his son. As such, the accusation that Dean isn’t taking care of it couldn’t be more cutting.

It also impacts on the brothers’ dynamic because, as we’ve seen throughout the season, Dean has been trying to maintain an image of himself as the top dog in their relationship, but John’s behaviour here marks Dean as occupying the lowest rung of the ladder in terms of family status - an observation that the Demon will also make and exploit in “Devil’s Trap” (s1e22).

A few years ago, I read the novel Life of Pi, by Yann Martel. One of the early chapters contains a description of circus lion training, and I was struck by its resonance with what I’d observed of the Winchester family interactions. Martel begins by explaining that, to control the lions, the trainer must become the de facto alpha of the pride. He continues:

It is interesting to note that the circus animal that is most amenable to the circus trainer’s tricks is the one with the lowest social standing in the pride, the omega animal. It has the most to gain from a close relationship with the super-alpha trainer. It is not only a question of extra treats. A close relationship will also mean protection from the other members of the pride. It is the compliant animal, to the public, no different from the others in size and apparent ferocity, that will be the star of the show, while the trainer leaves the beta and gamma lions, more cantankerous subordinates, sitting on their colourful barrels on the edge of the ring.
Yann Martel, Life of Pi p.44/45.

Over the course of the season it has been established that, in his dealings with John, Dean has been compliant to a fault, and John has made full use of his willingness:

[“Asylum” s1e10]

On the other hand, Sam’s role as the rebellious son, challenging the authority of their alpha-male father, identifies him as the beta of the pack and potential future alpha.

I can imagine the beta and gamma lions described by Yann Martel don’t appreciate being left on the edge of the ring, out of the action, and no more does Sam. (Interestingly, we will see an apt visual demonstration of this later in the episode when John sends Dean on an errand while Sam is left behind in the motel room, pacing backwards and forwards like a frustrated animal trapped in its cage.) And, in the following scenes, John’s continued refusal to share information and involve his sons in the decision making soon provokes a major confrontation.

In the car, Dean is reading up on vampires - from Elkins’ journal, perhaps? – and show takes the opportunity to expand on its SPN specific lore while setting the scene for the domestic dispute that’s about to occur. Again, I admire the way the writers subtly drip feed in the exposition between the drama and action sequences.

DEAN
(Reading) Vampires nest in groups of eight to ten. Smaller packs are sent to hunt for food.
Victims are taken to the nest where the pack keeps them alive, bleeding them for days or weeks.
I wonder if that's what happened to that 911 couple.
SAM
(Grumpily) That's probably what Dad's thinking. Course it would be nice if he just told us what he thinks.
DEAN
So it is starting.
SAM
What?
DEAN
Sam, we've been looking for Dad all year.
Now we're not with him for more than a couple of hours and there's static already?
SAM
Hmph. No. Look, I'm happy he's ok, all right? And I'm happy that we're all working together again.
DEAN
Well good.
SAM
(Unable to help himself) It's just the way he treats us, like we're children.
DEAN
Oh God.
SAM
He barks orders at us Dean, he expects us to follow 'em without question.
He keeps us on some crap need-to-know deal.
DEAN
He does what he does for a reason.
SAM
What reason?
DEAN
Our job! There's no time to argue, there's no margin for error, all right?
That's just the way the old man runs things.
(Ibid.)

Dean’s argument seems valid, up to a point, but, on the other hand, the brothers have been sharing information and responsibility all season and they’ve been getting the job done just fine – a fact that Sam implies in his response:

SAM
Yeah well maybe that worked when we were kids but not anymore, all right. Not after everything you and I have been through, Dean. I mean, are you telling me you're cool with just falling into line, and letting him run the whole show? (looks at Dean challengingly)
DEAN
(Giving Sam a long look; weakly, as if he's convincing himself) If that's what it takes.
(Ibid.)

Sam is not happy about this.

Perhaps it’s Dean’s subservience that particularly irks Sam. Except on those occasions when John has inserted himself into their hunting rhythm, making Dean feel he his father's authority to lay down the law, the brothers’ relationship has been working because they’ve acted as a team. On occasion Dean has even sought guidance from Sam: for example, in “Home” where we saw him list several possible cases then prompt Sam to make the decision about which one they should pursue.

[s1e09]

Notably, he tries to maintain top-dog status whilst seeking authority from Sam by simultaneously feminizing him. And so long as Dean has included him in the decision-making process it seems Sam has been content to play the game. Maybe he even prefers to let Dean be the “big brother”, so long as he isn’t an ass about it. But now John blows in with his alpha energy and Sam as beta (and next generation alpha) feels the need to challenge it, and he hates to see Dean just roll over. Hence, when John calls with instructions and Dean just accepts them without question, Sam sees red:

INTERIOR. IMPALA. NIGHT.
SAM is driving.
DEAN
(on phone) Yeah Dad. All right, got it. (hangs up) Pull off at the next exit.
SAM
(Angry) Why.
DEAN
Cause Dad thinks we've got the vampire's trail.
SAM
(very angry) How.
DEAN
I don't know; he didn't say.
SAM guns the engine, DEAN looks at him like he's crazy. DEAN turns to look at JOHN'S truck as SAM overtakes it and passes it.
Once in front SAM slams on the brakes, causing the Impala to swerve sideways in front of JOHN's truck. They both stop.
(Ibid.)

And now we get the big confrontation with Sam demanding answers, John barking orders, and Dean stuck in the middle trying to keep the peace.

While I have every sympathy with Sam’s frustration with his father’s authoritarian attitude, I tend to agree with Dean here that this is neither the time nor place for a showdown, not to mention the stunt Sam pulled swerving in front of John’s truck was downright dangerous. Clearly, he’s driven by rage and ego rather than practicality and it’s left to Dean to present the voice of reason, which is an interesting reversal of their typical roles. It’s also interesting that Sam’s face is shown in shadow here, perhaps signifying he has been taken over by something dark in this moment. It might be said that John has the power to bring out the demon in Sam. 🤔

Another notable thing about this scene is the way it’s framed in regard to the characters’ respective heights. Although Jensen Ackles and Jeffery Dean Morgan are similar heights (both around the 6’1” mark) and Jared Padalecki is 6’4”, the perspective makes Dean look by far the shortest of the three, emphasizing his omega status in the family pack dynamic.

On the other hand, the height difference between Sam and John seems de-emphasized, while John’s stockier build allows him to come over as more imposing. The overall impression given is of two equally powerful men going at it.

When Sam brings up the subject of when he left for college, the altercation starts to turn physical. John goes so far as to start poking and pushing Sam, and he grabs his collar at one point, but Sam refuses to be intimidated.

This is the scene that convinces me that Sam is not physically afraid of Dean. Their relationship is complex and there are aspects of it that I believe Sam fears but, if he’s prepared to go to head with John in this manner, I can’t believe he would ever be physically intimidated by Dean.

Nevertheless, Sam allows himself to be physically hustled back to the car by his brother, twice. And, despite Dean’s comparatively diminutive stature in this scene, John also allows himself to be talked down. I suspect both he and Sam are simply relieved to have a face-saving “out” from the conflict.

I’ve seen it proposed that, in the absence of a mother figure who might traditionally arbitrate between an authoritarian father and his rebellious son, Dean takes on that maternal role instead. Since we saw him fulfilling a similar parental function recently in “Something Wicked”, it seems a plausible interpretation of the interplay we see here.

But something significant has happened in this exchange that we shouldn't overlook: beneath the physical posturing and bluster John has revealed a hint of vulnerability: "your brother and me, we needed you." And, importantly, both parties got to air the crux of their issues, the points of emotional hurt that underpin the anger: "You walked away!"; "You closed that door!" Perhaps with a little time and reflection, this might provide an opportunity for reconciliation.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Mon, 09 Mar 2026 03:27:14 GMT

"Dead Man's Blood" (cont.)

The brothers retrieve a letter from the P. O. box, and it’s addressed to J. W.

As they sit in the car, debating whether to open it, there’s a knock on the window and Dean almost leaps out of his skin but, it turns out, it’s only John.

Oh wait. I mean, wow, it’s John!

It’s a nice touch that before this happens, while they’re retrieving the letter from the post office box and while they're discussing it in the car, we see the brothers scanning around them for potential threats, specifically not to be caught off guard in this way. So, when John catches them out regardless, we can infer that he is extra special sneaky.

Having heard the news about Daniel, John has hot-footed it to Colorado. He reveals that he was watching the brothers while they searched Elkins’ cabin, and bestows some rare praise on the boys:

SAM
(softly) Why didn't you come in Dad?
JOHN
You know why. Because I had to make sure you weren't followed.... by anyone or anything. Nice job of covering your tracks by the way.
DEAN
(looking a little proud) Yeah, well, we learned from the best.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

It seems Elkins was a mentor to John who taught him hunting skills in the early days after Mary’s death, but they “had kind of a falling out”. Perhaps Sam isn’t the only one who finds John difficult to get along with 😉 Either that, or hunters in general are just ornery so-and-sos. John takes the letter from the brothers and begins to read it. The SPN Companion provides a facsimile of the message. Whether it’s an actual copy of the original prop, or just Knight’s head canon of what it said isn’t clear, but it implies Daniel and John were peas in a pod:

John
If you are reading this, I'm already dead. I don't know who's more stubborn between us, but, well, you know. It's a damn shame to have to say goodbye this way. But if you knew the truth of it, you'd probably have killed me yourself. You see, old friend, I've got the colt. Least I HAD it - can't right say who or what might have it now. Check my safe, the combination's one you can remember - 3-8-2-11. If it ain't there, just follow the trail of my blood. I really do pray you get the gun. And put a silver bullet right between that bastard's yellow eyes.

Nicholas Knight, Season 1 Official Companion (p.107)

The combination is certainly one that John is unlikely to forget: Mary’s date of death in reverse.

Having read the letter, John demands to know if the brothers saw an antique colt revolver at the cabin. When Sam questions him about it, he isn’t exactly forthcoming – the start of a pattern that will cause issues later:

JOHN
If Elkins was telling the truth, we gotta find this gun.
SAM
The gun -- why?
JOHN
Because it's important, that's why.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

Sam points out they don’t know what they’re hunting yet and, despite the evidence we saw to the contrary in the opening scene, John insists they’re what Elkins “killed best” 🤔 and we get the revelation that finally identifies the episode’s monster of the week:

JOHN
They were what Daniel Elkins killed best: Vampires.
DEAN
Vampires? I thought there was no such thing.
SAM
You never even mentioned them, Dad.
JOHN
I thought they were extinct. I thought Elkins and -- and others had wiped them out. I was wrong.
(Ibid.)

Should have got that admission in writing; it may never happen again. 😉

Then we get John’s iconic speech that starts rewriting what viewers know about vampires, and begins to establish the Supernatural version in its place:

“Most vampire lore is crap. A cross won't repel them, sunlight won't kill them, and neither will a stake to the heart. But the bloodlust, that part's true. They need fresh human blood to survive. They were once people, so you won't know it's a vampire until it's too late.”

Significantly, he emphasizes that the blood must be fresh. This notably differentiated Supernatural vampires from the version popularized by Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel where reformed vampires could live off pigs’ blood from butchers and donated blood from hospitals. John’s speech makes it clear that this is not an option for these vampires. Even in SPN season 2 where Lenora’s nest have learned to live off cattle blood, it is still implied that it needs to be fresh from the animal. If it were not fresh, it would presumably be equivalent to “dead man’s blood” or, at the very least, couldn’t be guaranteed not to have come from a source that has since died. This point seems to be missed or forgotten in the show’s later seasons.

A nice directorial touch that, once again, highlights the show’s economy and efficiency in its storytelling is that John’s speech is given as a voiceover that plays across a scene where the vampires are partying by the side of a road as they wait to ambush unsuspecting travellers. In this way, a scene that might have been just static exposition in a conversation between John and his sons is conveyed while using visuals that are dynamic and interesting.

The Supernatural Wiki has an interesting note about the cars the vampires are shown with:

The vampires in this episode drive classic muscle cars. They have a 1966 Chevrolet Corvette Sting Ray C2 and a 1969 Chevrolet Camaro RS/SS.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood#Trivia_&_References

Perhaps the similarity between their chosen transport and Dean’s iconic Chevy draws a conscious parallel between the vampires and the Winchesters. After all, both are hunters of a kind, albeit with a different choice of prey.

When we’re first shown the pack’s intended prey, a young woman is teasing her date about his choice of fashion, a loud shirt that has a distinctly 70s look to it.

I wonder if this might be an in-joke for fans former Buffy fans; in the BtVS pilot she was able to spot a vampire because he was wearing dated, out of fashion clothes:

Might even be the same shirt 🤔

BtVS s1e01

But, in our show, the fashion victim is literally just that . . . while an apparent road accident victim turns out to be the predator:

The scene showcases another SPN twist: rather than the more familiar Dracula fangs, a second set of particularly vicious looking teeth descends. John Shiban has explained that the inspiration behind this particular innovation was rooted in actual folklore:

“Certain vampires lived among people, and we figured they could only have done that if they had retractable fangs. We based the fangs on the idea of shark teeth in rows.”
Nicholas Knight, Season 1 Official Companion (p.109)

And, in the Supernatural: Then and Now podcast, assistant director and X Files alum Kevin Parks describes how the creepy visual was achieved with a mixture of practical and CGI effects: a shot was taken of the actor leering with his own teeth, then another with the prosthetics in place, and a post-production transition effect created the illusion of the second set descending. It’s a particularly visceral image that readily suggests the difference between the neat little puncture holes that we formerly associated with vampiric feeding, and a far more horrific impression of victims’ throats being torn out.

TBC

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Tue, 03 Mar 2026 05:35:05 GMT

Next scene finds the boys in Nebraska. Dean’s scouting the local newspapers while Sam’s checking online for leads in neighbouring states. But pickings are slim, and it seems Dean’s still trying to hook Sam up with Sarah from “Provenance”:

DEAN
(Smirking) Hey you know we could just keep heading east. New York. Upstate.
We could drop by and see Sarah again. Huh? Cool chick man, smokin'. (he whistles)
You two seemed pretty friendly. What do you say?
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

Is show trying to tease us with the idea that there’s still hope for Sam and Sarah? (Spoiler alert: there isn’t.)

SAM
Yeah, I dunno, maybe someday. But in the meantime, we got a lot of work to do Dean, and you know that.
(Ibid.)

I doubt I noticed the subtle little nod back to the pilot in that line when I first watched this episode, but now that “we’ve got work to do” has become a major catchphrase for the brothers, it’s hard to miss.

Dean acknowledges Sam’s point but with a sigh and an eye roll. Maybe he was hoping to distract Sam from “the work”. We’ve seen evidence in recent episodes that he’s lost enthusiasm for hunting, and maybe now he regrets (allegedly) dragging Sam back into it and wishes he could restore the apple pie life his younger brother had been trying to build back then.

Sam finds a case in Colorado of a man killed in a suspicious bear attack/robbery and when he mentions the name, it strikes a chord with Dean who quickly searches through John’s journal:

SAM
You think it's the same Elkins?
DEAN
It's a Colorado area code.
(Ibid.)

It’s a small thing, but I’ve always found it interesting. Do you think Dean just happens to know the Colorado area code? Or does he know the codes of all the states, because that would be quite a feat. I mean, my country only has six states and two territories, and I know the codes of . . . maybe three of them?

Yeah, you’re right. I’m probably over thinking this. Still, my head canon is that he has indeed memorized the area codes for all fifty states, and this is another subtle nod to his oft-underestimated smarts.

Or, it’s just convenient to the plot. Whatever 😉

There’s another backward nod when Sam finds a salt ring round Elkins' door, like the one in John’s motel room in the pilot.

SAM
Hey, there's salt over here. Right beside the door.
DEAN
(flicking through ELKINS' journal) You mean protection against demon salt, or 'oops I spilled the popcorn' salt.
SAM
It's clearly a ring. You think this guy Elkins was a player?
(Ibid.)

The journal is just like John’s except we’re told it dates back to the 60s. Meanwhile we discover the cabin is being watched by a creepy figure in the shadows.

Sifting through the detritus from the fight, Dean notices scratches on the floor. “Death throes, maybe?” Sam suggests, but Dean’s not so sure. He rips a sheet of paper from a notepad and lays it over the scratches, using the sticky blood residue to secure it in place on the floor (ew).

Smart Dean is being smart again. 😊

Shading over the page with the pencil reveals the message in the scratches.

You know, I hate to nitpick . . . (Oh, who am I kidding? I loooove to nitpick 😉) but I gotta ask, when did Elkins get the opportunity to scratch a bloody message into the floor? Last time we saw him he was pinned to the desk by two burly vampires and, though we didn’t actually see his death, the screams over the blackout certainly implied it. I mean, I reckon that guy was dead. But that’s just a guess on my part. 😉

Nevertheless, Dean hands the recovered message to Sam who identifies the three letters and six digits.

They make a great team, don’t they? 😊

The figure of John Winchester seems to be haunting this scene like a spectre . . . rather like that creepy figure watching the cabin, in fact . . .

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Thu, 26 Feb 2026 11:31:25 GMT

Supernatural, Season 1
Episode 20, “Dead Man’s Blood”
Written by: Cathryn Humphris and John Shiban
Directed by: Tony Wharmby

Warning: image heavy post.

“Dead Man’s Blood” is the first of three episodes that feature Jeffrey Dean Morgan as guest star as we lead up to the season finale. It’s also the first episode in the series that features vampires as the monster of the week. Eric Kripke has revealed that he originally didn’t want vampires in the show because he felt they’d been amply covered by Buffy the Vampire Slayer* (which is valid but, also, ironic since vampirism became such an important metaphor as the seasons progressed). Once he was persuaded, however, both he and writer John Shiban were determined to find new and fresh ways to depict vampires compared to other shows and movies. Nicholas Knight, author of the Supernatural companion books, notes that there was a wealth of material from which they could draw inspiration: “[Vampires] usually have inhuman strength and speed, and heightened senses, like night vision. Beyond that, vampire lore is so vast, with so many variations, that it’d be impossible to say definitively what a vampire is.”*

Typically, Kripke wanted to draw principally from genuine folklore rather than popular media: “John and I both felt that if we were going to do vampires, we’d have to do our own version, based more on real folklore than what people know to be vampires, which is mostly based on the original film Dracula [1931]. But there’s every permutation of vampire throughout every culture since the beginning of time and we got to pick and choose elements that aren’t as well known.”*

One of those elements was the way the teeth were visualized. Shiban recalls how the idea of retractable fangs was developed: “Certain vampires lived among people, and we figured they could only have done that if they had retractable fangs. We based the fangs on the idea of shark teeth in rows.”*

Part of the freshness was achieved by “de-bunking” some popular conceptions. For example, Supernatural’s vampires are unaffected by crosses, and less vulnerable to sunlight than the usual portrayals.

Co-writer, Cathryn Humphris credits Kripke with the idea of dead man’s blood being poison to vampires*, but I don’t think this one was entirely original. I’ve always assumed the inspiration came from the scene in the movie Interview with the Vampire (1994) where Claudia tricks Lestat into feeding from a pair of dead boys he thinks are just sleeping, and their blood all but kills him.
*Supernatural: The Official Companion Season 1

Not all the innovations survived beyond the first season, however. “Dead Man’s Blood” is the only episode where we see the vampires’ eyes flash (in a similar fashion to those of the shapeshifter in “Skin”). Their abilities and senses also seem to vary through the seasons: in this episode they are shown to have inhuman speed and heightened senses (mostly), but these traits seem to come and go in later seasons to serve the purposes of different plots. This first depiction remains my favourite, though.

British born director Tony Wharmby is an X Files and Night Stalker alum, so he could be counted on to fit in with the gothic, noir look that the early show was cultivating. The opening scene is visually striking, with beautiful use of light and shadow:

The gentleman sitting at the bar, we will learn, is one Daniel Elkins and, as the camera focuses on a loose-leaf binder containing a singularly familiar kind of notes, we may surmise that we are being introduced to another member of the hunting fraternity.

A conversation between the bartender, Beth, and another customer reminds us how hunters may be viewed by outsiders:

MAN AT THE BAR
(To Beth) Thought they caught the Unabomber.
BETH
Yeah, poor Mr Elkins lives all alone, up the canyon. Sits here every day,
going through his papers, making his little notes. He's a nice old man; he's just a nut.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.20_Dead_Man%27s_Blood_(transcript)

It also reminds us that psychosis and delusion have been a recurring theme throughout the season. In “Home” for example, John’s obsession with a supernatural cause for Mary’s death led his business partner to doubt his mental stability, and the brothers also have been accused of insanity by civilians on more than one occasion. The idea that the supernatural may indeed be a shared psychosis always remains an interpretive possibility under the surface of what we’re shown through the pov of the main characters.

The atmosphere changes, tense music plays, and Elkins raises his head. An expression of alarm touches his features right before a group of newcomers enters the bar.

Nice camera angle.

Clearly there’s something threatening about these people, but it’s interesting that Elkins seems aware of their presence even before they come in. Perhaps Sam isn’t the only hunter with a sixth sense 🤔

As the bartender asks for their order, show drops one of those little jokes that can only be appreciated on rewatch.

Beth turns to ask Elkins if he’d like another drink, but he’s already gone. We cut to a scene of him racing back home and anxiously fumbling to unlock the door. But, once inside, he discovers that he has somehow been beaten back to the cabin.

Once again, he seems preternaturally aware of her presence before she appears.

The scene continues to be a masterclass in how to subtly and economically convey information to the viewer. A shot of the cabin wall is another hint of Elkins’ hunter status:

It eerily resembles John’s motel room in the pilot (below left), and Sam's wall from "Phantom Traveler" (below right):

The painstaking attention to detail in the set dressing is another credit worthy feature of the early seasons.

A flash of the eyes reveals the visitor is a supernatural creature, if we hadn’t guessed already. But what kind? The camera shutter effect resembles the shapeshifter from “Skin”, but the dialogue suggests something different: the creature’s comment implies Elkins has aged since their last meeting and she hasn’t, suggesting she’s an immortal or at least long-lived being, whereas what we were told in “Skin” indicated that shifters age the same as humans.

Elkins whips out a knife and bullseyes the creature’s chest, but it has no effect. If the blade is silver, which it could well be since he’s a hunter, then perhaps we can rule out shifter; but we soon find this is just a diversionary tactic so he can get into the next room, where he locks the door and pushes a heavy bookcase in front of it. Then he opens the safe and takes a case out of it revealing an ornate revolver.

We can see that the case originally housed thirteen bullets of which five remain. Regular viewers might be speculating at this point. Silver bullets? Consecrated iron, like the rounds that were mentioned in “Something Wicked”? In time we will learn that it’s more complicated than that.

Supernatural Wiki describes the gun used in the series as: “a replica Colt Paterson 1836 cap and ball modified to fire metallic cartridges. On the barrel of the gun is inscribed a Latin quote from Psalm XXIII:4, ‘non timebo mala’, meaning ‘I will fear no evil’."
https://supernaturalwiki.com/The_Colt

According to the podcast, this gun was originally designed to be muzzle loaded but, in this scene, Elkins has to take the gun apart to load it, then put it back together again. This makes for some great dramatic tension, of course, but one can’t help but wonder why he wouldn’t simply keep it loaded? 🤔 And later, when we discover what the creatures are and learn the full significance of the Colt, we might question why he would waste it on vampires at all? We soon learn that he’s supposed to be a vampire specialist; why wouldn’t he keep a machete or two close to hand? Reasons, I guess 😉

Meanwhile, the female is busting through the door, despite the bookcase, while her buddies burst through the skylight, land on their feet then leap the desk in a single bound.

We get the impression that these creatures are supernaturally strong, agile and fast. As they grab Elkins, the Colt drops to the floor, and the female creature picks it up.

That is what this episode is all about, after all. But who knew this antique Colt would turn out to be so pivotal?

And the significance of the earlier quip about “dinner plans” finally lands as we hear Elkins scream over a black screen.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love from "Provenance" (A Masterpost)

fanspired — Sun, 15 Feb 2026 02:17:44 GMT

"I can get my own dates." "A fine example of American Primitive." "I'm sure you're many things, Sam."

"Dean, would you get your mind out of the gutter please!" "I've got to go do . . . something . . . somewhere."

"What do you care if I hook up?" "The pain I went through . . . I can't go through it again."

"Low sodium freaks!" "That's my boy."

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Tue, 10 Feb 2026 04:09:57 GMT

"Provenance" cont.

The epilogue begins with some explanatory exposition:

DEAN
(Holding up some papers) This was archived in the county records. The Merchant's adopted daughter Melanie.
Know why she was up for adoption? 'Cause her real family was murdered in their beds.
SARAH
She killed them?
DEAN
Yeah. Who'd suspect her? Sweet little girl. So then she kills Isaiah and his family.
The old man takes the blame. His spirit's been trying to warn people ever since.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.19_Provenance_(transcript)

Sarah wonders why the little girl did it.

SAM
Killing others? Killing herself? Some people are just born tortured so, when they die, their spirits are just as dark.
DEAN
Maybe. I don't really care. It's over, we move on.
[Ibid.]

The conversation reminds me of one that Sam will later have with Molly in season 2, “Roadkill”. On both occasions, Sam speculates on the motivations of angry spirits while Dean is dismissive. It’s something he doesn’t like to think about because that would humanize the spirits and muddy the saving people/hunting things ethic. He prefers a worldview where the things he kills are just monsters. On this occasion, things still seem fairly black and white since they assume the little girl was born evil and, hence, was always a monster. But Sam’s use of the word “tortured” introduces a hint of grey areas that both brothers will be forced to confront in the second season; Farmer Greeley from “Roadkill” is a far more nuanced character, and when Sam talks about him the parallels between the Winchesters and the things they hunt become more readily apparent. And while Dean is initially reluctant to acknowledge the lingering humanity in Molly’s spirit, in the end he grudgingly concedes that “she wasn’t so bad . . . for a ghost”.

At this stage, however, the brothers still retain their image as unalloyed heroes so, when it’s time to leave, Dean hangs back like a gooseberry, still hoping for a pat on the back from the pretty girl.

And he’s a little grumpy when she fails to acknowledge his contribution:

DEAN looks from SAM to SARAH. SAM stares at DEAN until he gets it.
DEAN
I'll go wait in the car. See you, Sarah.
DEAN
(Grumbling) I'm the one that burned the doll, destroyed the spirit, but don't thank me or anything.
[Ibid.]

I’m inclined to agree, Sarah might have thrown him a Scooby Snack under the circumstances, but she still has eyes only for Sam.

😆

In the equivalent goodbye scene in early script, Sarah reveals that she intends to stop using her mother’s death as an excuse, and plans to move to New York and pursue her painting career seriously. If the early draft intended her evolution to parallel Sam’s pre-Stanford, then this development would have suggested that she had now reached the point that Sam was at before he left home, and perhaps implied there was still hope that he might return to Law one day. In the aired episode, however, it has already been established that Sarah’s artistic aspirations are firmly in the past and there’s no suggestion here that she will not continue her role in the family business. Nevertheless, she still takes care to leave Sam with a positive message:

SARAH
You know there's a lesson in all of this.
SAM
What's that?
SARAH
We all got through this in one piece. I didn't get hurt.
SAM
(Laughing) Yeah I'm glad for that.
SARAH
So, maybe you're not cursed. Maybe . . . maybe you'll come back and see me,”
[Ibid.]

but his eyes say "no, I won't"

and her eyes say, "I know you won't".

Outside the house, Dean watches the couple part company at the door and shakes his head in frustration.

While, from inside, we get a long lingering shot of Sarah looking sad at Sam’s departure.

But then there’s a knock at the door!

And smoochies! 😍

Dean watches, this time with great satisfaction. At the end of the day, his ego is but a trifle next to his pride when his little brother finally gets the girl!

He gets into the car and, we presume, he drives off and leaves Sam there. The early script was more explicit, closing with a candlelit scene of the couple making love. Personally, I’m glad the aired episode chose to end with the visual equivalent of the traditional dot dot dot. I think it was more appropriate at this stage of Sam’s journey. What do others think? Would you have liked the goodbye scene to end in the bedroom? Or were you happy to wait until season 2, “Heart” to see Sam engaging in full intimacy?

NB:

1/ Just a reminder, for those who are interested, copies of Sarah Blake’s casting sides with their glimpses of the early draft of “Provenance” are available from Supernatural Wiki at https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.19_Provenance#Sides,_Scripts_&_Transcripts

2/ If I recall, in one of my earlier posts, I took a little poke at the Supernatural Then and Now podcasts for not acknowledging their sources for background trivia on the episodes they review, but at the end of the podcast for “Provenance” I was happy to note that they did indeed credit both Supernatural Wiki and Nicholas Knight’s official Supernatural Companion books, so my apologies if I just missed that on previous podcasts.

Coming soon: Scenes I love from “Dead Man’s Blood”.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Tue, 03 Feb 2026 07:40:08 GMT

"Provenance" (cont.)

Warning: image heavy post.

Sarah’s face as she watches the brothers dig up a grave is priceless. ““You guys seem to be uncomfortably comfortable with this,” she observes.

Sam explains that this isn’t the first time. “Still think I'm a catch?” he asks archly, and they share an awkward chuckle.

There are some lovely visuals in this scene: for example, this shot beautifully framing their silhouettes beneath the shadow of a particularly magnificent tree . . .

Then, after Dean throws the match, illuminated by the fire from the grave.

After the salt ‘n burn they drive to Evelyn’s house to similarly dispatch the painting, just to be sure. Sarah decides to accompany Sam into the house, but Dean elects to stay in the car.

It seems Dean can see nothing inappropriate in Sam hitting on Sarah in her dead friend’s house 😆 He even puts the radio on, presumably to drown out anticipated sounds. 😉

Over the radio, those watching the show on streaming channels hear these lyrics: “this is what it’s like, I’m in love. This is what my life could become.” They seem like a positive omen for Sam, but the music choice when the episode originally aired was less encouraging: “Bad Time (to be in love)”, by Grand Funk Railroad.

Either way, Sam is unimpressed. Cue one of the brothers’ trademark wordless conversations 😊

(Please click on images to view gifs provided by my kind friend )

Inside the house Sam and Sarah notice the painting has changed again: the girl and razor are missing. They hear sinister girlish chuckling, then the front door slams and Dean can’t get it open, so they start hunting for salt or iron. We’re most fortunate that the script was revised before for the final cut of the episode since, in the early draft the painting was in the auction house, and the attack took place there instead of Evelyn’s house. Just think! We might never have had Sam’s iconic line:

😲

Also, Sarah’s father originally bought the painting, making her an owner and therefore a target of the girl’s spirit, but in the aired episode the attack is simply retaliative and both Sam and Sarah fight the spirit together.

The use of partial shots that focus on the razor and the doll effectively build tension before the girl is finally revealed, and the camera pans from the doll up the girl’s body to her face so we can see the two are dressed identically.

“That is just so wrong!” Sarah complains – which it is, of course, and that’s why Supernatural loves the evil child trope so much 😁

Sam dispels the spirit with the fire iron, while Sarah provides the vital information that can defeat it:

SARAH
Well back then they use to make the dolls in the kids’ image, I mean everything, they would use the kid's real hair.
SAM
Dean, Sarah said the doll might have the kid's real hair. Human remains, same as bones.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.19_Provenance_(transcript)

This makes her an equal partner in the fight, thus removing the uncomfortable victim/saviour association that tainted their relationship in the earlier version of the scene. She even helps Sam when the spirit traps him under the furniture and he returns the favour by throwing himself on top of her and pulling her out of the way when the little girl threatens her with the razor blade.

Meanwhile, Dean races back to the mausoleum and tries to break into the case that contains the doll, first using his fists, then the butt of his gun, to no avail. He turns away in frustration, but then he looks down at the gun in his hand realizes . . .

And shoots the glass. I love that the show includes this little poke at a popular movie trope where characters attempt to break something with a gun butt instead of the obvious and more efficient projectile housed in the chamber. 😁

The FX team usually love to make a meal of a ghost’s demise, but I notice the little girl’s spirit is dispatched comparatively swiftly, in mere moments.

Perhaps they decided prolonging the agony would be a bit much where a child is involved.

And then we see her image return to the painting:

I wonder if that is intended as a reminder that the “spirits” we see manifested on the show are never more than an electro-magnetically projected image of the person they were in life, not the person themselves.

Meanwhile, Sam has found himself in a somewhat compromising position with Sarah,

So, when Dean calls to ask, “are you good?”, I can’t help wondering if there’s a little double-entendre in play when Sam glances at Sarah then responds, “not bad.” Is he cheekily inferring a different meaning in the question than the one Dean intended?

Is that a little boast, Sammy? 😉

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Wed, 28 Jan 2026 08:38:11 GMT

"Provenance" (cont.)

Sarah shows up at Sam and Dean’s motel room, and we learn that she’s spoken to the police; she’s kept the brothers out of her statement so far, but she insists they tell her what’s going on: “who’s killing these people?” she demands. Now we get the big revelation scene, but it doesn’t come out of the blue in the middle of a date as it did in the early script. There are no romantic connotations at all, and certainly no tacky erotic response from Sarah; it is simply a necessary statement of the facts, to a witness who is already involved – and it comes only once the brothers have exchanged a glance of agreement that the circumstances demand it. “It's not 'who',” Sam tells her. “It's 'what' is killing those people.”

Even though - as Sam points out - Sarah saw the painting move, she is still reluctant to accept the truth:

SARAH
(Agitated) No...no I was...I was seeing things. It's impossible.
DEAN
Yeah well, welcome to our world.
SAM
Sarah, I know this sounds crazy...but we think that that painting is haunted.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.19_Provenance_(transcript)

Sarah scoffs but, although she is going through the motions of denial, the tears in her eyes reveal that, internally, she is wrestling with the new reality.

Nicely understated but telling performance from Taylor Cole here.

Altogether, Sarah’s induction into the supernatural world is achieved far more smoothly, naturally and realistically in the final script. And her response to the situation once she’s processed the shock is important:

SARAH
Look, you guys are probably crazy, but if you're right about this? Well, me and my Dad sold that painting that mighta got these people killed. Look I'm not saying I'm not scared because I am scared as hell but...I'm not going to run and hide either.
SARAH strides to the door.
SARAH
(Turning back) So are we going or what?
(Ibid.)

It’s reminiscent of the scene in “Dead in the Water” where Dean reveals that he isn’t fearless, but he tries ever day to be brave. Sarah's sense of responsibility is also a very Winchester trait. In this way, she earns her place as a worthy romantic interest for Sam, by joining the brothers on the hunt. This point is emphasized as she receives the seal of approval from Dean.

Back to Evelyn’s house then, and Sarah expresses concern as she watches Sam picking the lock on the front door:

“You've already lied to the cops. What's another infraction?” Dean retorts, continuing the show’s theme of erstwhile law-abiding citizens being corrupted through their contact with the Winchesters.

Comparing the haunted painting with the copy of the original that they attained from the librarian, the brothers confirm the differences: the father looking down at the daughter, the open razor, and – an important clue – the painting behind the family has been changed to depict the Merchant family crypt.

SARAH
What are you guys looking for?
DEAN
Well if the spirit's changing aspects of the painting, then it's doing so for a reason.
(Ibid.)

So, next stop is the local graveyards, an activity that seems to make Sarah uncomfortable. (Buckle in, Sarah. It’s all downhill from here!)

SARAH
So this is what you guys do for a living?
SAM
Not exactly. We don't get paid.
(Ibid.)

I love her ironic punchline.

The phrase is commonly translated as “congratulations”, but not in the sense of “well done”. It’s specifically used when someone has been blessed with good fortune. Taylor Cole is a master of wry tone and delivery.

Here is a nice directorial touch: the low camera angle makes a feature of the family name as Dean approaches the crypt . . .

And then the bolt cutters drop purposefully into frame:

The interior is suitably eerie: murky, dusty, and they have to beat through cobwebs as they enter and light on a macabre tableau within.

Sarah notably singles out the doll: “that right there is the creepiest thing I’ve ever seen”, she says. Another hint of her prescience, perhaps? Or just foreshadowing on the part of the writers. Sam helpfully exposits that preserving a child’s favourite toy in a glass case by the headstone or in the crypt was a practice of the time. Meanwhile, Dean notices that there are only four urns. “Daddy dearest isn’t here.”

And we cut to a scene outside county offices. All this time we have watched Sarah being led through the mechanics of a typical hunt with well crafted economy, while the spooky atmosphere of the episode has been maintained throughout. But now there's a break from the horror tones and we get a scene filmed in bright daylight while, after some swift exposition, the romantic subplot is developed:

SARAH
So what exactly is your brother doing in there?
SAM
Searching county death certificates trying to find out what happened to Isaiah's body.
SARAH
How'd he even get in the door?
SAM
Lying and subterfuge mostly . . .
(Ibid.)

Sam isn’t glossing over the unsavoury nature of what he does. Given the conversation they’re about to have, it’s likely that he’s deliberately attempting to create distance between himself and Sarah but, as he soon discovers, she isn’t so easily discouraged.

At this point he notices a stray eyelash on her cheek:

SAM
You have a...uh....you have an eyelash on your right...no...uh...you know wha -- t
SARAH reaches, but has no idea where it is.
SAM
(laughing) Do you mind if I -- get it?
SARAH
No.
(Ibid. [My emphasis].)

It's a small detail, but it seems significant that he is careful to ask for her consent before encroaching on her personal space. It’s a courtesy he’s seldom afforded himself.

“Make a wish,” he says once he’s captured the rogue lash:

It’s a cute and subtly intimate moment that provides an opening for a more personal dialogue:

“Is there something, here, between us?” Sarah asks. “Or am I delusional?”

Sam assures her she isn’t but, explains that he doesn’t think pursuing the relationship would be a good idea because he likes her – the logic of which escapes her 😆

SAM
Look, it's hard to explain. Ah--It's just when people are around me -- I don't know, they get hurt.
SARAH
What do you mean?
SAM
I mean like physically hurt. With what me and my brother do, it's.... (Sam breathes.) Sarah, I had a girlfriend. And she died.
And my Mom died too. I don't know, it's like, it's like I'm cursed or something. Like death just follows me around.
(Ibid.)

Similar sentiments have been expressed earlier in the season, but not by Sam. It’s an echo of comments that Lori Sorrenson made about herself in “Hook Man”. Now, although it’s likely that such notions were already in his head, I think Lori’s speech helped to distil them and bring them into the forefront of his mind. (That girl had a lot to answer for, imho. 😒) Sarah, on the other hand, has a far more positive message for Sam. As he continues to explain that his concern is to protect her, she gently points out that his argument is fallacious and, not to mention, inherently chauvinistic:

SAM
Look, I'm not scared of much, but if I let myself have feelings for anybody...
SARAH
You're scared they'd get hurt too. (Sam looks down.) That's very sweet. And very archaic.
SAM looks back up.
Sorry?
SARAH
Look I'm a big girl Sam, it's not your job to make decisions for me. There's always a chance of getting hurt.
SAM
I'm not talking about a broken heart and a tub of Haagen Dazs. I'm talking about life and death.
SARAH
And tomorrow I could get hit by a bus. That's what life is.
(Ibid. [My emphasis].)

Here she expresses a central theme of the show, and the fundamental lesson the Winchesters continually refuse to learn: everybody dies. Their inability to deal with loss and move on from it is the fatal flaw that keeps them trapped in their dance of death, the “mortis danse” that was highlighted with a circled “1” in the pilot episode.

E1.01

And she follows up with another vital point: “I know losing somebody you love -- it's terrible,” she acknowledges. “You shut yourself off. Believe me, I know. But when you shut out pain, you shut out everything else too.” [My emphasis]

Again, she zeros in on another of Sam’s fatal weaknesses: he responds to pain by attempting to cut himself off from his feelings. The writers often dramatize this figuratively by showing him distancing himself from Dean, who represents his emotional side – both good and bad. But, as Sarah implies, his emotional side is also the source of positive and needful traits – such as instinct, compassion and empathy, for example. These are the qualities that keep him human. Without them, he is left only with cold logic to drive his decisions - and logic untempered by human feeling is a recipe for moral error. (And equally, of course, so is emotion unrestrained by rational thought.)

I think Dean’s instinct was spot on when he said that Sarah could be good for Sam. Had he been able to keep her wisdom in his life, how differently might things have turned out, I wonder? Ultimately, though, he closes the conversation with another logical fallacy: “You don't understand,” he tells her. “The pain that I went through... I can't go through it again.”

He naively believes he can avoid pain and loss by eschewing romance, unaware that what he went through with Jessica was just a foretaste of the greater loss he has yet to face.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Sun, 18 Jan 2026 11:32:33 GMT

"Provenance" (cont.)

Sam has noticed there are differences in the painting, and Dean theorises the changes might provide clues that could help them stop the murderous spirit. “We gotta get back in and see that painting,” he says, “which is a good thing cause you can get some more time to crush on your girlfriend.”

But Sam has become impatient with his brother’s matchmaking:

SAM
Ever since we got here, you been trying to pimp me out to Sarah. Just back off, all right?
DEAN
Well, you like her don't you?
SAM raises his arms and eyes to the ceiling.
DEAN
All right, you like her, she likes you, you're both consenting adults...
SAM
(Frustrated, rising voice) What's the point, Dean? We'll just leave. We always leave.
DEAN
Well I'm not talking about marriage, Sam.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.19_Provenance_(transcript)

After an initial dig about Sam being cranky, Dean actually drops his annoying big brother persona, and we have a rare opportunity to see him expressing genuine care and concern. He is surprisingly gentle and respectful as he brings up the topic of Jessica, and the brothers have an open and honest conversation about the subject. It’s probably the most intimate conversation we’ve witnessed between them so far, and it’s a measure of how much they’ve bonded since the start of the season:

DEAN
(Sitting up on the bed) You know, seriously Sam, this isn't about just hooking up, okay? I mean, I, I think that this Sarah girl could be good for you.
SAM sighs and scratches his head. DEAN watches closely.
DEAN
(Softly) And... I don't mean any disrespect but I'm sure this is about Jessica, right? Now I don't know what it's like to lose somebody like that.... but... I would think that she would want you to be happy.
SAM is quiet and listening now, tears in his eyes.
DEAN
God forbid have fun once in a while. Wouldn't she?
SAM
(softly) Yeah, I know she would.
(Ibid.)

As Sam thinks about her, he smiles slightly, and I have to wonder if this is the first time since her death that he’s been able to think about her with fondness instead of pain?

But then he reveals “you're right. Part of this is about Jessica. But not the main part.”

Instead of replying, he just fixes Dean with a meaningful look, then his gaze drops away and we’re left wondering what the “main part” might be. Dean appears to catch on quickly, but it seems he doesn’t want to talk about it anymore than Sam does.

Their hunting vocation and the search for their father is, of course, an obstacle to serious relationships, but Sam’s already made that point, so that isn’t what he’s referring to here. Later in the episode he discloses that he feels cursed and sees himself as a danger to anyone he cares about, but it seems to me that would fall under the heading of being “about Jessica”, so I don’t think that’s what he’s talking about either. It occurs to me that perhaps he might be reluctant to become romantically involved while the question of his psychic powers remains unresolved. They haven’t been mentioned recently, but they will soon become an issue again in a couple of episodes, so perhaps this is foreshadowing. If so, it’s very subtle.

Whatever the elephant in the room is, the writers are content to leave it as a blank for the fans to fill with their own speculations. Would anyone care to offer their thoughts as to what it might be?

I love the way Dean watches his brother with one sly little eye while Sam resigns himself to calling Sarah . . .

And learns that her father has sold the painting to a new owner, who we find in her home doing a spot of solitary late-night reading.

We get a creepy shot of Isaiah’s head turning in the painting, then we see the razor blade reflected in the lenses of Evelyn’s spectacles while she takes a tea break:

To be honest, I find the reflection a bit corny and implausible since it seems unlikely the blade would appear isolated like this from any glimpse of its carrier, plus it moves unrealistically slowly and smoothly. Nevertheless, it’s a nice visual, and I find it effective despite my nit-picky reservations. 😉

Throughout the episode the smart use of camera angles avoids giving the game away too early. The pov attacker shots have all been taken from above the victims - in this case because Evelyn is sitting down and, earlier, because the husband had fallen on the floor - cleverly forestalling the revelation that the murderous spirit is a child.

When the boys arrive at the house, they are joined by Sarah who has insisted on coming against Sam’s recommendation. She is startled when, on failing to shoulder through the door, Dean starts picking the lock and Sam tries to break through the windows.

SARAH
What are you guys, burglars?
SAM
I wish it was that simple. Look you really should wait in the car. It's for your own good.
DEAN gets the door open and SAM quickly follows him inside.
SARAH
The hell I will. Evelyn's a friend.
SARAH runs in after them.
(Ibid.)

It’s an important line because it shows that Sarah shares the brothers’ ethic of putting saving others over their own safety.

She’s unprepared for what she finds inside though as, upon tapping her friend’s shoulder, the woman’s head rolls back to reveal her throat has been sliced almost completely through.

Then Sarah looks up just in time to see Isaiah’s painted head move. I have to say, I struggle to believe that her attention would stray to the painting in that moment, let alone notice a detail like that, rather than remain riveted on the shocking neck wound. I confess, the first time I watched, I didn’t even notice the movement myself and I had to go back and rewatch to check what they were referring to when they talked about it in the next scene.

That’s her “OMG” moment? More than nearly-headless Evelyn? 😲

But I do still think the moving painting FX are effectively creepy for their time.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Tue, 13 Jan 2026 11:58:00 GMT

Provenance (cont.)

The next morning Dean informs Sam that he must have dropped his wallet the previous night and they have to go back and get it. While the brothers are searching the warehouse Sarah emerges dressed more casually than we last saw her.

Every time we see her from now on there is less glamour and more earthy practicality about her appearance as she becomes more involved with the case, and it occurs to me that perhaps the show kept her in her glad rags for the “date” scene so it would be more impactful when she rolls up her sleeves to help Sam with the dirty work.

I Love Sam’s “busted!” expression, and Dean trying to look all casual in the background 😄

Sam claims that they’re there to say goodbye but, at that moment, Dean conveniently produces the allegedly lost wallet.

That moment when you realize your brother’s set you up.

Then makes his excuses so he can leave Sam and Sarah alone.

Smooth, Dean.

I love the knowing little wink Sarah gives him 😉

Despite Dean’s matchmaking efforts, Sam still insists that the brothers are leaving town, until he spots the painting, whole and back in its frame, being carried across the warehouse by staff Shocked, he hastily questioning Sarah about it, and he’s even less smooth than Dean:

SAM
So...what do you know about that painting?
SARAH
Not much -- just that it creeps me out. We sold it to the Telescas
at a charity auction the night they were murdered.
SAM
(raising his voice) Yeah, and now you're just going to sell it again?
SARAH
As much as my Dad wants to, no, I won't let him. I think it'd be in bad taste.
AM
Good. Yeah. You know what? Don't. Don't. Make sure you don't, okay?
SARAH
Why? Don't tell me you're interested in that?
SAM
(Flustered and backing up) No. No, God, no. Not in buying it, no. You know what, I gotta go,
I gotta take care of something. But umm, I will call you back...I will call you, I'll see you later.
SARAH
Wait, so you're...not leaving tonight?
SAM
No-o-o, I guess not. I'll see ya.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.19_Provenance_(transcript)

Leaving Sarah mystified and confused.

I do wonder if Sarah sharing that the painting “creeps her out” might be a surviving remnant of the suggestion in the early script that she has a degree of psychic intuition herself. If so, it’s a considerably more subtle hint than the original palm reading scene.

Outside, we’re treated to the classic shot of the brothers simultaneously opening the doors, climbing into the car and closing the doors again in unison. Flummoxed, they conclude they need to find out more about the family in the painting, which leads them to a local library, and us to another of Supernatural’s lovely character roles.

The librarian, who seems to really enjoy his job, is played by Jay Brazeau, who also clearly relishes the role and makes the most of his brief appearance. Incidentally, the actor later appeared again as Dr Corman in season 5, “My Bloody Valentine”.

"I dug up every scrap of local history I could find," he tells the brothers and, once again, we see the show adding interest to an exposition scene by painstakingly including character details like Dean idly leafing through a book on guns while the librarian presents his findings.

Then there's the front page headline on the newpaper that reports Isaiah Merchant slaughtering his family:

It’s the first of several references to the doomed vessel that appear in the show, and may be a hint of the brothers’ fate as they steam toward their own personal iceberg.

"There were whispers that the wife was gonna take the kids and leave," the librarian continues:

"Which of course you know in that day and age, um ....so instead, old man Isaiah...well he gave them all a shave."
He draws his hand across his throat with appropriate noises, laughing.
DEAN joins in but stops when SAM gives him bitchface.
https://supernaturalwiki.com/1.19_Provenance_(transcript)

I love the man’s macabre glee as he describes the murder.

Much to the brothers’ chagrin, he reveals that the family were all cremated. Nevertheless, he’s able to provide a helpful copy of the portrait that differs interestingly from the version we’ve been familiar with.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.

Scenes I Love . . .

fanspired — Tue, 06 Jan 2026 07:04:43 GMT

"Provenance" (cont.)

Back at the motel, the brothers fall into the activities that illustrate their traditional roles with Dean taking care of the practical task of weapons maintenance while Sam pursues his research for the case. I love these little details that ensure there’s never any dead time in the exposition scenes. Dean sharpening the knife is an activity that keeps the scene visually interesting while maintaining the character trait that Dean needs to keep himself physically occupied, and it also keeps the day-to-day routine of hunting present to our minds.

Sam has managed to get the provenances from Sarah (without having to “con her or do any special favors”. “Dean, would you get your mind out of the gutter, please!”) and he’s discovered that the list of owners tallies with the names and dates of deaths noted in John’s journal, so he’s wondering whether the painting is haunted or cursed.

I love that line 😄

The brothers break into the auction warehouse, affording us an opportunity to enjoy their athleticism 😁

And we also witness their expertise at disabling alarm systems. In the first season it was established that the brothers were both geniuses in their own ways, so it bothered me when, in later seasons, they seemed to be de-skilled so they required help from guest characters to do things that they’d previously managed perfectly well by themselves.

Dean takes the time to slice the canvas from the frame. It makes it more portable, I suppose, but it does beg the question: what if it's the frame that's haunted? 🤔😉

Burning the painting make for another beautiful visual.

The painting reconstituting itself is an unexpected twist and, also, a well-executed special effect.

TBC.

.

Please follow the "episode rewatch" tag to be notified when new reviews are posted.