Hello, hello, my friends,
After the weirdest and wildest six months of my life, I’m finally fully back to immersion in a cozy, little writing cave, and I couldn’t be happier. That said, it took me a beat to find a moment to sit down and formally celebrate this incredible news with you:
We have officially found our January Andrews, and I couldn’t be more thrilled.
Phoebe Dynevor has joined the EHCU!
Everyone always asks me if I pictured anyone in particular when writing any of my books, and the truth is, largely, no I did not. I am much more concerned with picturing the layout of their kitchens. I see my characters in slivers, little bits of detail that I love about them, and that’s one of many reasons that I’ve always been adamant that an actor doesn’t need to match up physically to the book’s description of the character they’re portraying. For me, the performance and energy matter so, so much more. That said, Phoebe is so right for this part.
Yulin, Karina (our incredible producer), and I have talked so much about what matters most to us in seeing these characters come to life, and for January, the vision was always to find an actor who could genuinely and deeply encompass BOTH Januarys (Januaries?). The one that Gus knew way back when—the “fairy princess,” the optimist, the girl with starry eyes—and the one he finds today in North Bear Shores. A woman awash in heartache, melancholy, a tightly worn if completely unnatural cynicism.
We couldn’t have gotten luckier than we have with Phoebe. She has everything we need, in spades, and I cannot wait for you to see how perfect she is. I’ve spent the days since the initial announcement basking in your excitement. You really can’t imagine how much your support means to me. Like, I promise you that. You’re underestimating it.
Now on to what I know you’re dying to hear about next: Gus. The short answer is, we don’t have our Gus yet. The longer answer is, we’re getting closer by the day, and I am absolutely ecstatic with how things have been shaping up. Yulin’s and my phone calls are very exciting these days. This process is long and slow, and very complicated. Yulin and I have talked about doing a private Q&A at some point to demystify the whole Hollywood process, but as a fresher, I talked a bit about how casting works in this old letter. If you scroll down to the Who will play Poppy & Alex section, I try to explain a few of the factors that go into finding the exact right person.
I know that many of you, like I, hold Gus extremely close to your heart. I actually can say that across all the adaptations we’re working on, I’ve never felt more pressure to Get It Right than I do with this one. It’s so important to me that you know we’re leaving no stone unturned in this process. When we find our Gus, he WILL be the best possible Gus for this version of the story.
Some of your favorites won’t be available in our shooting window, some have a pay quote that won’t fall within our budget, and some just won’t be interested. Here’s another excerpt from that old letter about Alex and Poppy:
“That doesn’t mean they will necessarily be your mental Alex and Poppy, and I want you to know that’s okay… I hope you’ll continue to feel free to imagine these characters however you want, because they belong to you, no matter what happens with the adaptation. I think it’s helpful to think of an adaptation like you would a play, or a superhero franchise. The characters will always exist separate from the plays and films themselves. There are so many different Batmans, and none of them is the real Batman; it’s all about what different actors can bring to a character.”
And despite all of those caveats, let it be said, I’m not worried. We are looking at some seriously amazing Guses and we will find the right person for the job. And while rumors will swirl in the meantime, just know that when there’s something to report, I will tell you personally right here in the Grocery List.
Now, on to another burning question I’ve seen floating around: Will this movie be in theaters? Let me just say, that is the hope and the plan. Not just mine, Yulin’s, and Karina’s, but the whole team at 20th Century. We want you to get to go watch this movie in a packed room with your best friends and laugh, cry, moan, and scream together. That’s been our dream and goal from the beginning, and I’m so thrilled 20th is on board with that plan. (I also do have to say… readers are the reason studios are starting to see these movies as theatrical. The way that you guys show up for the things you love is huge, and helps a very risk-averse industry realize there’s actually very little risk involved here.)
In the last few years, I’ve done a lot of work to be more present in the moment, instead of looking forward to all of the good things I’m excited about, and all of the horrifying worst outcomes my anxious brain can concoct, but there honestly is a small part of me that wishes we could fast-forward to release weekend, so we could all just experience this together already.
I also feel a bit spoiled because I got to have this experience with PWMOV already, and it was so magical just desperate to recreate it for everyone else. First there were the fan screenings Netflix set up around the country (I got to stop by two of those and watched the movie with readers at the first one!), and then, on release day, I partnered with Lyft to recreate the magic.
There’s this place in Manhattan that has a bunch of small personal theaters available for rent, and Lyft booked them all and brought a bunch of book clubs, booksellers, and friend groups to come wine and dine while they watched the movie on the big screen. Best of all (for me personally), they brought me in to crash the screenings and give a teensy intro and meet some of you.
Your joy was so contagious and getting to share this moment with you was so unbelievably special. Pics below!
One final note before I get back to my draft cave (👀), the Valentine’s Day “Written By Emily Henry” sweatshirts are almost sold out—when they’re gone, they’re gone! If you want one, now’s your chance. (I have one of each but have been particularly obsessed with the red sweatshirt with pink script.) Once again, huge thanks to everyone who participated in the Palentine’s Giveaway. My team and I spent a couple days reading your responses and I loved learning more about you and your best friends and it was inspiring and sweet and life affirming to see your love for each other.
That’s all I’ve got for now, but surely tons more to follow soon,
Em
P.S. Current grocery obsession is simply the concept of room service, because I’ve been traveling a bit too much to keep my fridge well stocked :(.