While going through Letterbox, I found this account, Cláudio Alves that has put together a list of films eligible for Oscars throughout the entire history of the Academy Awards. And I was incredibly impressed and thrilled to find such lists.
And such lists got me thinking: I've often ranted about how the Oscars get it wrong, every year, and have always done so. So how would I have done it? If I had been presented with these ballots every year, how would I have voted every time? In contrast, not taking into consideration Academy eligibility rules, which are often confusing and contradictory, what films would have stood out to me each year? So, this list was born.
This list will…
While going through Letterbox, I found this account, Cláudio Alves that has put together a list of films eligible for Oscars throughout the entire history of the Academy Awards. And I was incredibly impressed and thrilled to find such lists.
And such lists got me thinking: I've often ranted about how the Oscars get it wrong, every year, and have always done so. So how would I have done it? If I had been presented with these ballots every year, how would I have voted every time? In contrast, not taking into consideration Academy eligibility rules, which are often confusing and contradictory, what films would have stood out to me each year? So, this list was born.
This list will be part of an ongoing personal project where I go through every Academy Awards and make two lists: The first, a retrospective ballot based off actual eligible films and using official categories for that ceremony. The second will be a retrospective of my own personal awards that I choose each year, without taking into consideration Academy eligibility or how the Academy defines the release of each film.
This is my retrospective ballot for the Eighty-Ninth Academy Awards.
Special note here, the list of eligible Oscar nominees does not include short films so, I'm using the release date to give myself as best an idea of what to pick from as I can, so what I choose may not completely accurately reflect what was eligible at the time since eligibility for shorts is weird a lot of the times. But it's the best I can do.
Partner to the Retrospective Golden Hourglass Awards: 2017.
Nominees taken from: boxd.it/c1dXc
Categories:
Best Picture:
Silence ***Winner***
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
The Edge of Seventeen
Hail, Caesar!
The Handmaiden
I, Daniel Blake
The Lobster
The Swiss Army Man
The VVitch
Best Director:
Martin Scorsese - Silence ***Winner***
Park Chan-wook - The Handmaiden
Joel Coen and Ethan Coen - Hail, Caesar!
Kelly Fremon Craig - The Edge of Seventeen
Zack Snyder - Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
Best Actor:
Andrew Garfield - Silence ***Winner***
Ben Affleck - Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
Paul Dano - Swiss Army Man
Dave Johns - I, Daniel Blake
Dev Patel - Lion
Best Actress:
Hailee Steinfeld - The Edge of Seventeen ***Winner***
Amy Adams - Nocturnal Adams
Rooney Mara - Lion
Kim Tae-ri - The Handmaiden
Anya Taylor-Joy - The VVitch
Best Supporting Actor:
Daniel Radcliffe - Swiss Army Man ***Winner***
Adam Driver - Silence
Woody Harrelson - The Edge of Seventeen
Cho Jin-woong - The Handmaiden
Sunny Pawar - Lion
Best Supporting Actress:
Hayley Squires - I, Daniel Blake ***Winner***
Nicole Kidman - Lion
Tilda Swinton - Hail, Caesar!
Haley Lu Richardson - The Edge of Seventeen
Rachel Weisz - The Lobster
Best Original Screenplay:
Swiss Army Man ***Winner***
The Edge of Seventeen
Hail, Caesar!
I, Daniel Blake
The VVitch
Best Adapted Screenplay:
Silence ***Winner***
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
The Handmaiden
Lion
Nocturnal Animals
Best Animated Feature
Kubo and the Two Strings ***Winner***
Kung Fu Panda 3
The Little Prince
Moana
Mune: Guardian of the Moon
Best International Feature
Mune: Guardian of the Moon - France ***Winner***
Fire at Sea - Italy
It's Only the End of the World - Canada
Julieta - Spain
Land of Mine - Denmark
Best Documentary Feature
Weiner ***Winner***
Before the Flood
Everything is Copy
Fire at Sea
Zero Days
Best Live Action Short:
Curve ***Winner***
Kitty
Sing
Timecode
Woman in Deep
Best Animated Short:
Piper ***Winner***
Borrowed Time
Fox and the Whale
Love
Pear Cider and Cigarettes
Best Documentary Short
What Happened to Her ***Winner***
Joe's Violin
Pickle
The Search for Life in Space
Speaking is Difficult
Best Original Score
Swiss Army Man ***Winner***
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
The Handmaiden
Lion
Moana
Best Song
The Footsteps of My Dear Love- The Handmaiden ***Winner***
The Dragon Song - Pete's Dragon
Heathens - Suicide Squad
How Far I'll Go - Moana
No Dames - Hail Caesar!
Best Sound Editing
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice ***Winner***
Hacksaw Ridge
Rogue One
Star Trek: Beyond
Suicide Squad
Best Sound Mixing
Silence ***Winner***
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
The Edge of Seventeen
Elvis & Nixon
The Lobster
Best Art Direction:
Hail, Caesar! ***Winner***
The Handmaiden
Pride and Prejudice and Zombies
Silence
The VVitch
Best Cinematography:
Silence ***Winner***
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
The Lobster
Swiss Army Man
The VVitch
Best Makeup and Hairstyling
Star Trek: Beyond ***Winner***
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
Hail, Caesar!
Pride and Prejudice and Zombies
Suicide Squad
Best Costume Design
Hail, Caesar! ***Winner***
Pride and Prejudice and Zombies
Rogue One
Silence
The VVitch
Best Film Editing
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice ***Winner***
The Edge of Seventeen
The Handmaiden
Silence
Swiss Army Man
Best Visual Effects
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice ***Winner***
Doctor Strange
Rogue One
Star Trek: Beyond
Warcraft
--
Films with multiple nominations:
11: Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice
10: Silence
9: The Handmaiden
8: The Edge of Seventeen, Hail Caesar!
7: Swiss Army Man
6: The VVitch, Lion
4: The Lobster, I Daniel Blake
3: Moana, Suicide Squad, Rogue One, Star Trek: Beyond, Pride and Prejudice and Zombies
2: Nocturnal Animals, Fire at Sea
Films with multiple wins
4: Silence
3: Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, Swiss Army Man
2: Hail Caesar!