1. A film from 2025
2. a film from the 1920s
3. a Jeffrey Combs film
4. 5th film in a franchise
5. Written/directed by an IPOC
6. a film from 2015
7. a film from the 1930s
8. an animated Scooby Doo film
9. a Tony Todd film
10. the highest rated film on your watchlist
11. a Troma film
12. a film from the 1940s
13. starring a musician
14. a Japanese film
15. a film from 2005
16. a film from the Letterboxd top 250
17. a film from the 1950s
18. an A.J. Bowen film*
19. Dystopian future
20. From 1995
21. Dee Wallace
22. 1960s not seen*
23. Southeast Asia*
24. Remake/reboot*
25. From 1985
26. Oscar nom/winner involved
27. 1970s not seen
28. Italian
29. Classic Universal Horror film (1920-1960)
30. Lowest rated watchlist
31. Debra Hill
32. 1980s not seen
33. Video Nasty (select from HERE)
34. From 1975
35. Year you turned 13
36. Irish
37. 1990s not seen
38. French
39. From 1965
40. Set in a school
41. Hammer films unseen
42. 2000s not seen
43. Written/directed by a woman*
44. Spanish language
45. Short film (under 45)
46. Films from the "Bleeding Skull" books (pick from 1980s or from 1990s)
47. 2010 not seen
48. From 1955
49. Set in NYC
50. Original version of #24
51. Starring a Pro Wrestler
52. We pick from your watchlist
**BONUS FILMS: We each picked a gem we wanted to recommend**
Demons (1971)
Milk & Serial (2024)
Triangle (2009)