comrade_yui’s review published on Letterboxd:
reichardt methodically lays out the bleakness of our situation by converting our cathartic fantasies to their inverse expression: the quintessentially american ambition to 'be a hero', when applied to the environmental movement, means that what should be a mass mobilization becomes a way of cutting yourself off from the world to fulfill some unconsidered yearning for martyrdom, no matter how ineffective the terrorist act may be. the self-loathing of perceiving climate change, yet not being able to conceive of a meaningful way to combat it, gives rise to a fragmented worldview that sees activism as a series of consumer choices -- note how reichardt meticulously shows the transactions that go into our team acquiring their equipment, and that she ends the film with a man not victimized, but fondling the banal products of a system that he has had no effect on, and seeing others engaged in the same consumerism. his resistance has been a momentary blip in the state of affairs, and it served functionally as a weekend vacation excursion in-between jobs and relationships.
the structure of a thriller is used to interrogate the expedient and fleeting dreams of individuals and their individualism, this naive idea that you want to destroy the way things are, yet also return to your normal routine the day after, not affected by your own behavior. night moves is dostoyevsky to the core, especially demons, it is a completely unsentimental examination of how and why meaningful change does not occur: because, when we conceive of change, we only do so in terms limited to us and not on a societal scale. "people are going to start thinking. they have to.", and other similar vagaries are spouted, yet they read as hollow justifications for three people who might as well have some other reason to do what they're doing; the point of climate change is just a pretext for what is a nihilistic performance against a civilizational structure that they don't want to have a dialogue with, but merely hope to irritate into acquiescing towards a better future -- the dream of this trio is too small to do anything substantive, and too big to avoid staining their hands with blood.
flooded barren trees bare witness to them as they drift through the dam's river, which have become a silent graveyard, occupied by nearby campers with nylon tents and televisions and air conditioners and kids tired of walking -- the real enemy is the ease at which this scene is created and sustained through a network of capitalist products and markets, but you can't simply blow that up, there is no critical weak point that american heroes can attack, there is no martyrdom to be had, it is an invisible background process that foregrounds nature herself as a standing-reserve to be exploited and sold. we swim in these waters so often that it easy to take them for granted, and so even when we think we're revolting, that minor rebellion is anticipated, screened-out, and treated as yet another externality to be managed just like pollution is -- reichardt forbids the intuitive reverie found in violence done on a limited personal scale, and shows how it rebounds on its perpetrator three-fold; they can rebuild a dam, but your soul is a lake being drained sooner or later, and to not fully think through your efforts to save yourself and others is tantamount to begging for quick relief in a world where that is an increasingly rare resource.