cinemasauron’s review published on Letterboxd:
No matter how predictable it may seem for the majority of its runtime, We Are What We Are still manages to work as a solidly structured & cleverly paced horror that mainly relies on its carefully elevated tension & isolated setting to deliver a thrilling cinematic experience to the blood-thirsty fans of the genre. And at that, it vehemently succeeds.
A remake of the 2010 Mexican film of the same name, the story concerns a reclusive family that rigorously follows its ancient customs and is hellbent to keep its traditions alive at any cost. But when an unexpected tragedy strikes during a torrential downpour, the family finds its existence threatened, for the secret they've held on for so long is close to being exposed.
Co-written & directed by Jim Mickle, I've been meaning to check out his earlier works ever since I watched Cold in July and after sitting through this one, I'm convinced that he is one rising talent who knows how to create the right mood for the desired effect because even if the secret is out of the bag early on in this picture, there are still many moments which feel downright tense, all coz of their proper build-up.
Cinematography encapsulates the whole picture with a sinister feel that perfectly suits its gothic aura but its Editing could've used more trims to rid a few unnecessary moments. There isn't as much violence or gore as one might expect but the subject matter is still capable of churning the stomachs of many. And it benefits a lot from its smartly chosen cast who all chip in with solid efforts in their given roles.
On an overall scale, We Are What We Are is a welcome entry in its genre that feels incredibly refreshing despite the familiar touches, has a genuinely chilling vibe to it that several horror films of today lack, and it concludes on a bloody high with a shockingly twisted finale and then follows it up with an even more disturbing epilogue. One of the better Hollywood remakes and amongst the very few that improves upon the original. A definite must for horror aficionados.