Synopsis
An aged tailor recalls his life as the schoolteacher of a small village in Northern Germany that was struck by a series of strange events in the year leading up to WWI.
An aged tailor recalls his life as the schoolteacher of a small village in Northern Germany that was struck by a series of strange events in the year leading up to WWI.
白色緞帶, I lefki kordela, Det hvite båndet, Shiroi Ribon, Seret Lavan, Valge pael, Das weiße Band – Eine deutsche Kindergeschichte, Das weiße Band, La cinta blanca, Bílá stuha, Biała wstążka, Biela stuha, Bijela vrpca, A Fita Branca, Il nastro bianco, Beyaz Bant, O Laço Branco, Le Ruban blanc, 白丝带, Det vita bandet, Белая лента, Det hvide bånd, Η Λευκή Κορδέλα, 白いリボン, סרט לבן, A fehér szalag, Бялата лента, Бела трака, 하얀 리본, Біла стрічка - Німецька дитяча історія, Le ruban blanc, Banda albă: O poveste pentru copii germană, Valkoinen nauha, თეთრი ბაფთა
In The White Ribbon, director Michael Haneke seems to ask us: where does evil come from? This is a story told as a parable, to show us a world we deeply know. It is an inhuman look at humanity, showing us the root of an evil that is (and, more crucially, was) powerful. There is sharp black and white photography, accompanied by static camerawork, and this colourless, slow portrayal of life makes no comment upon it, instead just showing us the festering evil. The White Ribbon is cold, cerebral, and calculated, calmly deconstructing things and presenting them bleakly. It's an uncompromising masterpiece.
Spoilers from here onwards.
The White Ribbon is a story of children, specifically evil children. Throughout the film a…
I think this is one of the best films ever made.
I laugh for the first 25 minutes, thinking of Michael going to all of these lengths to talk about the events that lead to pre-War Germany.
Then the scene happens where the older sister and the boy are in the kitchen and he asks what death is and all of a sudden I'm crying my eyes out and then the movie gets so graphic and real.
I think this is one of the best films ever made.
It took me 24 hours to fully appreciate this film. Some things are so obviously gorgeous that you love them during the viewing: the cinematography, the pacing. But it can be difficult to distinguish the various plot points and characters, leading to confusion. While it turns out to be of little importance, as it so often does, it is nonetheless a gamble I'm always surprised film makers are willing to take.
I've got a thing about films that explore the nature of evil. I have very little patience for the obvious when it comes to that topic. Films about murderers, rapists, tyrants and their like never impress me too much when the film-maker's goal is to show what evil looks…
At a Q&A, Michael Haneke explained that he first wrote The White Ribbon as a book almost ten years ago. Financiers weren't eager to produce the film, so he waited for the opportune moment. He told the audience that his choice to shoot the film in black and white was to get the look of old photographs and used narration to put some distance between the film and the audience. The movie is as close to a novel as can be though, with the careful introductions of each character.
Haneke explains his reasoning behind this film: to show how children are the lowest in society's hierarchy, but they also our future. Some children seem like they're destined to be S.S. Officers, while Haneke insists that most of the youngsters are actually well-behaved.
They say it takes a village to raise a child, but if it’s this village, I think I’ll go ahead and take my chances on my own, thank you.
“I gave God a chance to kill me. He didn’t do it, so he’s pleased with me.”
Tracing back the haunted beginning of an unconsciously developing evil, every moment in Michael Haneke’s The White Ribbon carries the underlying horror of what we know will result from the societal conditions its characters perpetuate, as the seemingly unsuspecting children of the village will inevitably - after the events of the film - become the generation of Nazis. The film is careful not to limit these themes to a German context, instead examining how the impersonal, excessively authoritative structure of the time moulded the people in it; with the adults apparently uninterested in the emotional needs of their children, rather enforcing purist ideologies and…
Carefully digging into the origins of what generally lets violence & cruelty seep into our society, The White Ribbon (Das weiße Band) is an elegantly crafted, meticulously shot & patiently narrated drama that's thought-provoking, disturbing & riveting at the same time, and is presented in a manner that's destined to divide its audience.
Set in a fictional German village, taking place just before the onset of First World War and narrated by the schoolteacher who once used to reside there, the story follows the suppressed children of the villagers who seem to be at the heart of a series of bizarre incidents taking place in the village and having the characteristics of a punishment ritual.
Written & directed by Michael Haneke, the film has…
I'm not always in the mood for Hanake's often deliberately grueling brand of blunt novelistic psychological/metaphorical writing or pretentiously miserable and clinical "beauty has to suffer" observational style, but it felt right to wait this one out and clear up my biggest Palme d'Or-winning blindspot of his in a theater, which ended up being the right setting to really concentrate on some the specific off-putting textures and rhythms of how he translates his strict religious upbringing in Austria to an upsetting 1910s German village period drama. One that plays out a fable-like microcosm/test-run of an authoritarian hierarchy (filled with patriarchal abuse, religious fundamentalism, sexual repression and class-based suffering) that slowly bleeds into a strange and somber reflection on the broader…
I was expecting this from Haneko, but this is the most mean spirited movie I’ve seen. Every single shot just screams “I hope you and all your family dies in horrid, unbearable pain”.
A nice way to start 2021.
Best decanted in tandem with The Zone of Interest to savor the acrid bouquet of youth as it ferments into grotesque shapes and distills into abominable beings through the vine of generational trauma.
Evil doesn't just suddenly appear in human's mind, it plants, it forms, grows and strengthens from generation to generation, through abuse, harrasement and indifferent attitude in parent-child relationship. Who else if not Michael Haneke was perfect to make a film about origins of evil and more precisely about origins of fascism. Evil like a ghost floating through the village, appearing out of the blue, causing violence and chaos and going away in seeking of the next target.
In its entirety The White Ribbon isn't exactly the sharpest Haneke's work and not the bleakest, but the realest one, there's no exaggeration in how violence and abuse affect people's lives, especially in childhood, and that is the scariest and bleakest part of…