The Muhlenberg football team of the decade 2010-11 to 2019-20:

First Team Offense
OL       Willie Britt (2013-16)
OL       Ryan Malarkey (2016-19)
OL       Bryan Auvil (2012-15)
OL       Kyle Oprisko (2015-18)
OL       Michael Porembski (2010-11)
TE        Ryan Curtiss (2017-19)
WR      Nick Lamb (2014-16)
WR      Cody Geyer (2012-14)
QB       Michael Hnatkowsky (2017-19)
RB       Nick Savant (2014-17)
RB       Terrence Dandridge (2010-12)
 
First Team Defense
DL       Frankie Feaster (2016, 2018-19)
DL       Michael Hogan (2013-16)
DL       Greg DeLade (2011-14)
LB       Patrick McDonough (2010-11)
LB       Mike Luby (2013-16)
LB       Ian Gimbar (2011-14)
LB       Kwasi Ampomah (2016-19)
DB       Nate Corvil (2015-18)
DB       John Feaster (2013-16)
DB       Chris Hartzell (2010-11) 
DB       John Washington (2018-19)
 
First Team Special Teams
K         Connor Winter (2011-14)
P          Dan Deighan (2010-12)
KR       Nick Lamb (2014-16)
 
Second Team Offense
OL       Brian Biskaduros (2017-19)
OL       Domenick Mattia (2013-16)
OL       Frank Malandruccolo (2010-12)
OL       J.T. Bucsek (2014-17)
OL       Kenny Mulkeen (2016-19)
TE        Michael Long (2011-14)
WR      Max Kirin (2016-19)
WR      Isaiah Vaughn (2010-12)
QB       Nick Palladino (2013-16)
RB       James Diggs (2017-19)
RB       Max Cepeda (2014-15)
 
Second Team Defense
DL       Kenneth Cobb (2010-11)
DL       Frank Cresta (2016-19)
DL       Kevin Cellary (2011-14)
LB       Mickey Kober (2016-19)
LB       Jeremey Thomas (2011-14)
LB       Lenny Smith (2012-15)
LB       Mark Accomando (2010)
DB       Chase Nadell (2010-11)
DB       Tyler Cerbo (2011-14)
DB       Luke Wiley (2015-18)
DB       Michael Blank (2015-18)
DB       Amir Blair (2014-17)
DB       Shane O'Connor (2010-12)
 
Second Team Special Teams
K         Todd Spirt (2016-19)
P          Joseph O'Hagan (2016-19)
KR       Chase Nadell (2010-11)
 

---

Britt was named to the All-Centennial Conference first team three straight years and earned first-team All-America honors in 2016. Malarkey was an All-American in 2019.

A two-time Academic All-American, Auvil received All-CC recognition three years and was CC Scholar-Athlete of the Year twice.

Oprisko and Porembski were both two-time All-CC first-team picks.

Curtiss broke school and CC receiving records for tight ends and earned All-America honors all three years in a Mule uniform.

The program's all-time leader with 195 receptions in only three years, Lamb was a two-time first-team All-CC pick at wide receiver and a 2016 All-American as a kick returner.

Geyer caught 120 passes in only two seasons, earning All-CC honors both years.

Hnatkowsky was the 2019 CC offensive player of the year and needed only three seasons to break the career record for touchdown passes.

Dandridge (3,368 yards) and Savant (2,855) rank third and fourth, respectively, on Muhlenberg's all-time rushing list. Dandridge was a three-time All-CC selection.

Feaster, a two-time All-American and two-time CC defensive player of the year, holds the school record for career sacks.

Hogan was named to the All-CC team twice as a nose tackle. A three-time All-CC pick, DeLade recorded 20 career sacks.

D3football.com named McDonough an All-American in each of the first two years of the decade.

Gimbar (24½) and Luby (23½) are second and third, respectively, on the program's all-time list for career sacks. Both were named to the All-CC first team twice.

Ampomah was a three-time All-CC pick, making the first team once and the second team twice. 

Corvil returned three interceptions for touchdowns in his career and earned All-CC honors three straight years.

Feaster was the only Muhlenberg player in the decade to make the All-CC team four years in a row, making the first team three times.

Hartzell was an All-CC first-team corner in the first two years of the decade, and Washington was in the last year.

A two-time All-CC selection as a kicker, Winter also earned honorable mention as a punter.

Also the Mules' quarterback, Deighan received All-CC honorable mention as a punter in 2012.

Biskaduros, Mattia and Malandruccolo all made the All-CC first team once. Bucsek and Mulkeen were second-team selections once apiece.

Despite being a two-time All-American, Long has to settle for the second team. He held the Mules' tight end records until Curtiss came along.

The 2019 CC Scholar-Athlete of the Year, Kirin made the All-CC second team twice and caught 29 touchdown passes.

Vaughn was named to the All-CC second team as a senior and averaged 17.7 yards per catch for his career.

Palladino, the program's all-time leader in passing yards and the 2016 CC offensive player of the year, is another tough second-team pick.

A two-time All-CC second-team selection, Diggs ranks sixth all-time with 2,312 rushing yards. Cepeda was the 2014 CC rookie of the year.

Cobb set a school record (since broken) with 11 sacks in 2010 en route to earning all-region honors.

Cresta and Cellary both received All-CC honorable mention as juniors and advanced to the second team as seniors.

Kober, a two-time captain and three-time All-CC second-team pick, made 295 tackles in his career.

Thomas was named to the All-CC second team once and the All-CC first team once.

Smith and Accomando were both selected to the All-CC second team one time.

In both 2010 and 2011, Nadell was named to the All-CC second team as a defensive back and kick returner.

Cerbo and Wiley each earned All-CC honors twice.

Blank, Blair and O'Connor tied for the last defensive back spot; each made the All-CC second team once. Blair also was MVP of the 2017 ECAC Bushnell Bowl.

The CC all-time leader in points scored by a kicker, Spirt was chosen to the All-CC first team in 2019.

O'Hagan received All-CC honorable mention as a punter in 2017 and made the second team as a defensive back in 2019.