Gristle Von Raben - very sad, rich textured poem. thank you for trying to save the world, but none of us knew it was already lost to evil before it started, not even Adam knew.
Yellow-rose7 - Stunning verse. One to add to the replay pile. I'd love to hear this one spoken from a stage as I sit in the audience drinking rum and coke.
Joelpam - This poem really gave me chills. The way it mixes time, memory, and loss feels so heavy but beautiful at the same time. It makes you stop and think about how the past never really leaves us.
Mever1234 - What an astonishing piece raw, elegiac, and steeped in the ache of memory. It’s not just a lament for a lost friend, but a confrontation with time, silence, and the futility of trying to hold onto something that's already been swallowed by the tide. The imagery crashes like waves stark, luminous, and deeply human.
- From guest Julie (contact)
In my 1977 school poetry text, line 53 reads "or something had just run..." rather than "or something THAT had just run..." as in your version. I have no way of knowing which is right, but without the word "that" the line is more grammatically correct.
Also the words "five bells" where they occur as a line on their own in the poem, are not strictly part of the poem, but indicators of where the sound of five bells was to be given, when the poem was read out on radio, which was its original purpose.
And students might be interested to know that the word "dowsed" in line 25 actually means divined, as in a dowser who divines water; the spelling of the word meaning to put out a fire is "doused", which leaves one to wonder whether Slessor made a spelling mistake, or had some deeper intent...
MOD MESSAGE
Food for thought Julie. Many thanks for bringing it to our attention
Jim
- From guest Joy (contact)
Apart from ecstasies, your original spellings were correct. In Joe's journal he spells different as differant (twice), photos as photoes and curios as curioes. Slessor is showing that Joe was well-read but not an educated man.
Seasinger - It seems I was mistaken about the ship's bell ringing. It was the practice to ring 5 bells half way between the end of the second hour of watch and the end of the third hour. http://www.sizes.com/time/ships_bells.htm
Seasinger - This great poem is not a "war" poem. Very strange to find it in that category. It is an elegy for a friend who fell overboard at night from a ferry in Sydney Harbour, and whose drowned body was never found.
Query whether a ship's bell is ever rung officially 5 times. I'd be glad to hear from someone with shipboard experience who does know. I have read somewhere that it's always rung either 2, 4, 6 or 8 times, and that Slessor made up the idea of 5 bells to symbolise a sort of limbo or in-between time where he imagined his friend was. In the poem the phrase also has an overtone (no pun intended) of hearing an audible buoy clanging in the wash of a passing boat such as a ferry.
I-Like-Rhymes - Slessor lived in the days before the modern digital watches had become the universal phenomena they are now and for him a (wrist)watch was a device that contained a lot of "little fidget wheels" but that was not the time that governed his life as a naval officer. On board ship the time is divided into work periods called "watches" and these watches are timed by a system of bells being struck at given intervals. These are sometimes double and sometimes single strikes and in the flow between each sounding the time does not flow. For example the period known as Six Bells lasts until the next bell is struck.
The time period known as five-bells, as the notes above says, is the middle of one of those watch periods.
To my mind this is a metaphor for a sort of in-between time perhaps and signifies the time Slessor is spending contemplating life with and without his friend Joe.
- From guest Lola (contact)
I seriously don't understand this poem...any help???
MOD MESSAGE
The answers are in the comments if you read them, and the poem, carefully.
- From guest Phuc Huynh (contact)
can you tell me why the poem title is Five Bell? why it is not four bell or 2 bell? Is that the way to count time in a day ?
(please read the note at the bottom of the poem MOD)
- slessor was chiefly influenced by the death of his friend joe lynch to write this poem. funnily enough, when you study slessor, you realise how he has rather tried to distinguish himself from other australian poets by writing in a different style. generally, he did not like the australian style of rambling about the outback, and such..
- From guest Jonathan Cooper (contact)
There is a spelling mistake: "ectasies" should be "ecstasies". Also, is the jounal entry meant to have misspellings ("photoes", "differant", "curioes")?
Thanks for this resource; it helps me to understand the artist John Olsen, and his paintings of the same name, better.
Oldpoetry team Note:
corrected the spelling errors; Thanks for the assistance.
- From guest BoB_AtoA_Pi3 (contact)
i believe that as he refers to Joe he is also referring to humanity, how there is in the end no real purpose and how humanity is fragmented, isolated and unable to accept anything that they do not understand and how you only see fragments of Joe can be related how you can only understand fragments of humanity and life
- From guest Harry (contact)
Im am a year 10 student studying this at the moment and believe it is an amazing pice of poetry entailing both concepts of the inevitabe acceptance of death, which slessor speaks of first hand, retelling a memory of his old friend 'Joe'. It also reflects the ravaging affects of time in such a brilliant way. A five star poem which is just a fantast once you fully grasp the underlying message.
- From guest Brittany Chapman (contact) This is the first time I have read the poem 'Five Bells' and heard of Kenneth Slessor. Knowing that he was an Aussie make me proud to be one. The poem is a little confusing at times but all over I think that the poem is amazing. I would like to know what other experiences infulenced him to write this and other poems.
Liked it
Clever work
Enjoyed it
Good work.