@Joe Nation,
I used to love to watch it - constantly amazed at the quality of these non-professional singers. The last one I really remember is Fantasia - she was awesome - I don't know what happened to her after, but I remember at the time just being on the show was such a wondrous thing to her in her life - she was intensely grateful for the opportunity.
I haven't watched it in years because I've pretty much given up tv, but last year this guy was on and my daughter (who still watches it religiously - as well as x-factor and anything else with music - because she loves it and boy can SHE sing- called me downstairs and was like, 'Mom - don't you know this kid?' And it was ANOOP! I never taught him (because he was really smart and didn't need any of my remedial help) but he was in the student government and select choir, etc., etc...just an overall talented, smart and amazing student and wonderful person. So while he was on (he didn't win and actually - I bet his parents are happy - they'd probably rather he be an academic anyway for the long term) I watched it faithfully. Here he is:
But I am constantly amazed at the talent I find on youtube. As much as it's an outlet for people who love to sing (and want to perform - I love to sing, but I don't want to perform) it's a marketplace for people who love to hear people sing.
Here's one where I swear I think they sound at least as good as the original artists if not better-I had to listen to it twice and you can just hear that their voices are slightly different and almost better - and the guy plays the fiddle too and I'm thinking - who are these kids? I'd buy a record by them: