Ironically, even when I was born and bred in West Bengal, I am not much of a fish person. My mom though says I was very enthusiastic about fish as a child and catfish was my favorite. I for sure can’t recollect the species we mostly had at our home and I don’t think anyone even cared back then. They could though be easily distinguished with their prominent whiskers.

One of my aunts (mausi, masi) lives in rural West Bengal and they have huge ponds where they farm fish. I believe none of them are operational right now, but I remember, back in the 1990s and 2000s, she used to send us a variety of fishes – most prominently Bata, and others including tiny fishes called “chunu” and dried fishes called “shutki.”
We also had the usual Bengali staple of Rohu and Katla with the occasional Hilsa aka Ilish, Shoal, Bhetki, Tilapia, Pomfret, Silver Carp, Bangda, Girai and others.
When I got married and moved to the USA in 2014, fresh fish became rare but we occasionally had frozen fillets of Swai and Tilapia. When we got a car a few years later, mobility increased and we started going to Indian groceries and resumed with our favorite Rohu.
As our palette broadened, we started having a variety but mostly in restaurants. Since Neha is not very fond of fish having a gamey taste, we mostly end up eating those which don’t have a strong smell. Since I don’t have such a requirement, I have on occasions tried fishes beyond our usual but I never kept a note.
Below are all the fish species – with their scientific names if possible, I remember having eaten.
Magur (Clarias magur, Endangered) – I haven’t eaten any in a very long while and since they are now classified endangered, I will never be eating them again.
Singhi (Heteropneustes fossilis, Least Concern) – I haven’t eaten any in a very long while.
Tangra (Mystus tengara, Least Concern) – I haven’t eaten any in a very long while.
Bangda or Indian Mackerel (Rastrelliger kanagurta, Least Concern) – I haven’t eaten any in a very long while.
Girai aka Spotted Snakehead (Channa punctata, Least Concern) – haven’t eaten any in a very long while.
Shoal (Channa striata, Least Concern) – Very old but distinct memories of eating them.
Rohu aka Rui (Labeo rohita, Least Concern) – Native to India and perhaps the most commonly eaten fish by me and our families.
Katla (Labeo catla, Least Concern) – Native to India and one of the commonest eaten fish by me and our families.
Bata (Labeo bata, Least Concern) – My mom says this was the commonest fish masi used to send.
Tilapia – Not native to either India or USA and have been introduced for pisciculture in both the countries. Commonest ones available are Nile Tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus, Least Concern), Blue Tilapia (Oreochromis aureus, Least Concern) and Mozambique Tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus, Vulnerable).
Bhetki aka Barramundi (Lates calcarifer, Least Concern) – Native to India and popular as fish fry. I remember my frequent trips to Benfish for the same at Sector V, Kolkata.
Puti aka Pool Barb (Puntius sophore, Least Concern) – These are medium sized and great for frying whole or even as simple curries. I absolutely loved them.
Silver Carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix, Near Threatened) – Not native to India but farmed quite a lot in West Bengal including at my aunt’s farms.
Goldfish (Carassius auratus, Least Concern) – Not native to India and a popular aquarium fish, these were rarely caught and I remember them having a few times.
Shutki aka Bombay Duck (Harpadon nehereus, Near Threatened) – These were dried fish sent by my aunt, sometimes ready to eat and sometimes mom would cook. These were very smelly and only I ate them. I absolutely loved them.
Hilsa aka Ilish (Tenualosa ilisha, Least Concern) – It’s a very bony fish and I mostly had it when my Bengali friends made it and shared. Absolutely love it. We made it once at home but it didn’t turn out that good.
Pomfret/Pompano/Butterfish – Native to both India and USA, there is confusion regarding the species I have had in India and USA. The one from India is most likely the White Pomfret (Pampus argenteus, Vulnerable). We have purchased them a couple of times for making fish fry as a chakna when our families were here and they turned out amazing – in picture above. They have a strong smell when fried but taste heavenly. I purchased them again in March, 2026, when my mom was visiting. They were wild caught and $13 per lbs. Gemini AI suggests they were Florida Pompano (Trachinotus carolinus, Least Concern). They are sold as Silver Pompano. One of our friends made Pomfret fish curry for us sometime ago. I am assuming that was also Florida one.
Swai – Most probably Sutchi Catfish (Pangasianodon hypophthalmus, Endangered) but could also be Basa (Pangasius bocourti, Least Concern) since both are marketed as Swai in the USA. These and Tilapias were the first fish we got in the USA as frozen fillet. These are very low in nutrition and not native to the USA and are surrounded with controversy regarding their farming practices in South East Asia as also the contaminants present. There is unsurety about the species we got but since one of them is endangered, we STOPPED buying them.
Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar, Near Threatened) – We had it a few times at restaurants and Neha slowly got used to it. We often visit a close family friend in Virginia and we had Salmon curry at their place once and we liked it so we made the same at our home. Otherwise, we most shallow fry it or bake it. I absolutely love the crisp skin of the fish. The smoked Salmon bagel I had at St-Viateur Bagel, Montreal, Canada, was mind blowing.
Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss, Least Concern) – I remember having it once at Bonefish Grill, Towson. I had it again on 1/26/2025 at The Bonefish Grill, Bel Air, and absolutely loved it. The Chilean Sea Bass will have to wait.
Atlantic Cod (Gadus morhua, Vulnerable) – I remember having it a couple of times as fish and chips and in tacos.
Haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus, Vulnerable) – I remember having it a couple of times as fish and chips and in tacos.
Skipjack Tuna (Katsuwonus pelamis, Least Concern) – Occasionally as sushi and tinned ones for sandwich.
Sardine – Not sure about the species but got the tinned ones for having it in sandwiches.
Surmai aka Indo-Pacific King Mackerel (Scomberomorus guttatus, Least Concern) – I remember having it in a Konkani thali at Maratha Samrat, Pune, Maharashtra, when I was visiting India in November, 2022 and then again in October, 2025.
Mahi Mahi (Coryphaena hippurus, Least Concern) – I had it in tacos at Looney’s Pub, Bel Air.
Red Snapper – Not sure of the species because both the Northern (Lutjanus campechanus, Vulnerable) and Southern (Lutjanus purpureus, Least Concern) are found in the Caribbean Sea. We had quite a few varieties of fish during our Cancun, Mexico, vacation and while it was difficult to get the species name for most, some agreed it was Red Snapper. It has a very neutral whitefish taste so Neha also loved it.
Yellowfin aka Ahi Tuna (Thunnus albacares, Least Concern) – I had it in tacos at The Greene Turtle, Bel Air on 1/31/2025. It has a very distinct taste with a very red meat core.
Karimeen aka Green Chromide (Etroplus suratensis, Least Concern) – I had it at Ente Keralam – Poes Garden, Chennai and absolutely loved it.
Besides the above, I am sure I have had a few more varieties – including perhaps Swordfish, but I don’t remember them. We also had fish curry at Margaritaville Resort, Playa Flamingo, Costa Rica, and it was amazing but I didn’t enquire about the species back then. Even Neha loved it.
Besides fish, below are the other aquatic animals I have eaten.
Among all the aquatic animals, shrimps and prawns are my absolute favorite and I have had them multiple times in India as well. Since there are so many kinds usually sold together and they look similar, it’s difficult to specify the species.
The Bagda Chingri aka Tiger Prawn (Penaeus monodon) are a delicacy and larger in size and rather more expensive so not as commonly eaten.
The Golda Chingri aka Giant River Prawn (Macrobrachium rosenbergii) is used in the Bengali delicacy called Chingri Malai Curry.
The Indian Prawn (Fenneropenaeus indicus) is also commonly eaten.
I also occasionally had crabs sent over by my mausi or at her home. I also remember having crabs, octopus, sharks and lobsters at Indian restaurants.
When I moved to the USA, I started having some more including –
Calamari (Squids), Scallops, Oysters, Mussels and Clams. I have had these multiple times at restaurants and have made Scallops even at home.
I have also had a whole American Lobster (Homarus americanus, Least Concern) at a restaurant in Maine with just melted butter and a slice of lemon and absolutely loved it.
I love crab cakes and being a resident of Maryland’s Chesapeake Bay area, we just can’t have enough of it. They mostly use the famous Maryland Blue Crab (Callinectes sapidus, Least Concern) and for some of the best ones, head to Bel Air’s Looney’s Pub.
The Whiteleg Shrimp aka King Prawn (Litopenaeus vannamei, Penaeus vannamei), Atlantic White Shrimp (Litopenaeus setiferus) are some of the most commonly ones available in the USA.
























